Guild Wars 2

So when I got to the end I couldn’t kill scarlet. I just left the instance because it didn’t feel right. Now scarlet is forever fighting with Kasmeer. Here are my reasons for not killing Scarlet.
1. Taimi’s dream of meeting scarlet would be crushed. Taimi is my favorite character in the living story right now
2. Though Scarlet has had harsh methods no character I cared for was ever killed by her.
3. Scarlet is always trying to accomplish goals but All we ever do is beat her down for it. It feels like we’re bullies.
4. Scarlet deserves to see the fruits of her labor even from a jail cell.

I always liked choose your own adventure books which is why I was fond of the character stories however we have been put in a situation where we HAVE to kill scarlet to continue the story. Unless I am wrong. Are there other ways of completing the end instance I am unaware of?

When you tell Taimi she specifically asks if there was lots of blood and if you saw her guts. She’s not all that torn up about it. In fact, if you talk to her now she’ll tell you that she plans on growing up and killing her herself.

Taimi only wanted to meet Scarlet so she could kill Scarlet herself.