Guild Wars 2

I’m going to disagree with everyone (on the internet? No!) and say that the change to the crafting UI is not terrible. It’s not great, mind you. It has some rough edges, clearly. Once the fact that you need to hit enter to lock in a number is fixed, that annoyance will be gone.

Aside from that, the UI is basically the same, with the addition of a new option, the ‘invisible scroll bar’. As a concept, there’s nothing wrong with it. The only problem I see right now is that it needs a better acceleration curve. Big mouse movements need to jump the numbers up a lot faster, but small movements need to change the numbers much slower. That would take care of all the problems and get rid of the annoyance in getting to the number you want right now. Once that change is made, this actually is a unique UI idea and I’m surprised no other UI that I can think of has done something like this in the past.