Guild Wars 2

I tried forging four different endless tonics a few times, but I kept only getting back the one endless (rare quality) tonic that I hadn’t put in (since there are 5 endless tonics of which you have to select 4 to put in the forge). I never got an exotic version back, neither the gift dolyak tonic nor the toymaker’s tonic.

Is this intended? This is very different from my experiences last year. I wasted a lot of gold to come to this conclusion; this was not announced in the patch notes?

I think it was always a chance.. but not sure if they changed it completely. I was thinking about doing that as well.. but after your story I think I should wait until snowflakes are cheaper lol.