Guild Wars 2

1) Add ability to use guild chat to rank system, sometimes members need to cool off and step away from chat, but do not. As is all we can do is argue or boot them. Everyone has a bad day sometimes. With this ability we could change their rank and silence them for a bit.

2) Remove/add ability for member to visit the guild hall or not, to the ranking system. For example, with this ability we could require Recruits to earn access to the guild hall by gathering materials or completing a series of tasks. Having a setting in the rank system could be a great motivator to helping the GH grow. No interest, no access.

Your second suggestion was implemented over in WoW in the form of each quest reward giving ten percent “extra” money to the guild of the player.

This led to incessant spam guilds being created with the explicit purposes of (a) recruiting as many players, especially new players, as possible, and (b) thus channelling more money into the bank that the officers could use for themselves.

It did not result in higher quality guilds, it resulted in more guilds, used for the benefit of the people making them, at the cost of the players — because the guild didn’t do anything other than use them as disposable sources of income.