Scarlet is coming, let's analyze the poem

Scarlet is coming, let's analyze the poem

in Lore

Posted by: Remillard.8691

Remillard.8691

When it gets to the “lessons to teach/Divinity’s Reach” part it throws off the rythm for me. The rest seems good, though. A fumble on the writer’s part or intentional hint at Scarlet being a calculating, but still crazy woman? Not sure.

I’m guessing fumble. It’s been a long time since high school english and I’m not a poetry expert by any means, but because of the situation, it really ought to be a sing song chant, so the stress and rhythm ought to be consistent. After rereading it and thinking about it a bit, I guess it’s a little better than I thought. There are still things that bug me though.

Tick tock goes the clock
It’s al-most time for time to stop

Aside from clock and stop not being full rhymes, the rhythm seems right. The first line doesn’t have the same number of stresses but I can forgive that on count of it being the first line, and “Tick tock” being … er whatever that word is that means it sounds like the object or effect it’s describing. Anyhow, very singsong. You can imagine a little girl voice chanting along. I think counting syllables is probably beyond analysis here and I was never very good at sorting that out anyway. But stress rhythms are natural to hear.

Some-thing you all must un-der-stand
Your world is built on fog and sand

Putting the stress on the second syllable on “Something” feels unnatural, but it’s workable as long as you keep the sing-song in mind. It might have been better to write it as “Some thing” rather than “Something” which very definitely has the emphasis on “Some”.

You’re out of time, your jig is done
It’s time for Scarlet to have her fun

And here I am imagining their writer cursing the design team for giving the antagonist a two syllable name, because “Scarlet” completely screws up the line. The best you can do is try to slur Scarlet into a single syllable, but it’s not a name that does that very easily.

She has some hard lessons to teach
To the people of Divinity’s Reach

And here, you’re right. It’s completely broken at this point. I’m not even going to mark stress patterns because there’s no way to read this the way the prior lines have been read. I can’t even come up with a good alternate. You either go past tense with taught which doesn’t rhyme with reach, or you abandon the ‘*each’ rhyme and go with something else thematic. And referring to Scarlet again is going to be problematic every time it occurs because it’s Scar-let and never Scar-let.

So mark the date in perm-’nent ink
The hour is late-r than you think

“Permanent” and “later” are awkward as hell but you can kind of fudge past it with some slurring.

On the twent-ieth day she’ll start her games
And warm her hands over Kry-ta’s flames!

And again “twentieth” is awkward and “over” is awkward. “On” might have been better on the latter. I’m not sure there’s a good solution for 20th.

So overall, I’m forced to agree it’s not quite as bad as I thought, but there are still a lot of rough patches.

Scarlet is coming, let's analyze the poem

in Lore

Posted by: MaesterTed.6571

MaesterTed.6571

Didn’t wanna make a new topic about this, but about Scarlet: Wasn’t she supposed to be someone we would’ve already been somewhat familiar with, or someone we would at least have some degree of familiarity with?

Scarlet is coming, let's analyze the poem

in Lore

Posted by: Evans.6347

Evans.6347

The personal nemesis is yes. Conclude what you want out of this.

Joy to the world, ignorance is bliss

Scarlet is coming, let's analyze the poem

in Lore

Posted by: Konig Des Todes.2086

Konig Des Todes.2086

Actually, no.

We were told that we’d instantly recognize the personal nemesis. Meaning that it could be someone we all knew… or it would be someone who’s just that unique.

Scarlet is pretty unique… in her ugly pigtails.

Dear ANet writers,
Stop treating GW2 as a single story. Each Season and expansion should be their own story.

Scarlet is coming, let's analyze the poem

in Lore

Posted by: MaesterTed.6571

MaesterTed.6571

Ahhh, yes, correct. I didn’t remember the exact wording anymore. Thanks for clearing that up.

Scarlet is coming, let's analyze the poem

in Lore

Posted by: Mad Queen Malafide.7512

Mad Queen Malafide.7512

So far the only thing personal about this personal nemesis, is how she sometimes bugs, and relentlessly keeps ambushing the same player. It’s a bit of a shame that they’ve once again plucked a villain out of thin air with no clear motives. If it turns out she’s simply insane, then I will be very disappointed.

“Madness is just another way to view reality”
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D-On3Ya0_4Y)

Scarlet is coming, let's analyze the poem

in Lore

Posted by: Nihilus.3015

Nihilus.3015

Well seeing how it was sent in real life and not ingame, it doesn’t have to fit the lore.

AmateurNet