Dear Anet,
consider following my steps to a better PvP experience overall (skip the details if you dont need deeper inside into my ideas – oh and excuse my bad english at some points).
1. Remove Hotjoin.
2. Add an unrated Soloarena wich continious after winning. Same like the Gw1 Random Arena.
3. Polish your Leaderboards so that we have a visible and reliable rating. Furthermore Team Arena should represent teams not players.
4. Add a Monthly (Automated?) Tournament.
Details:
What PvP lacks the most at the moment is competition … the biggest incentive* to play.
A polished Leaderboard and a Monthly Tournament would solve this problem for the everyday life.
You have to register your team to face up to 31 other teams. In case there are more than 32 teams (wich I doubt there are at the moment) Leaderboard rating will decide wich teams are able to enter.
The rewards of said tournament should be big. Something like gems, a special skin, a stomper wich works like the wvw league stomper we`ll see soon. This stomper would get passed to the next month winner. Compare it to the golden, silver and bronze cape of Gw1 GvG. Oh … and of course you should reward a lot of rankpoints and glory (I imagine something like 50.000 here for the 1st place).
5. Add an accountwide/charackterbound unlock system wich uses glory.
Details:
Now when it comes to rewards … revamp your glory system.
Remove all the silly materials the mystic forge and that pvp locker. Instead use glory to unlock all the armor and weapon skins out there … even t3 and those shiny pve skins. Once unlocked we can use them as much as we want. But things should not be unlocked after 10 hours of play. Make dyes unlockable for your charackter with glory, too. You still got those rank merchants where you could unlock things only if you get the appropiat rank (I like the idea of bags, backpieces and maybe something to even make real ingame gold!).
6. Polish your rankpoint reward.
Details:
Remove those situations where more than 1 guy is capping a point for no reason. Rework the way rankpoints are rewarded. People should get rankpoints/glory if they win a game. Reward people for winning in unrated soloarena matches. For each continious win there should be a bit more rankpoints and glory (maybe it has a cap of 25 wins?). People playing rated Soloarena all day should get more rankpoints for winning than those winning a few games in unrated Solo Arena matches. Even more points should be rewarded for winning a Team Arena match. The best way to earn rankpoints tho should be participating in the Monthly Tournament – winning or not.
7. Work towards build variety regulary.
Details:
Rework a trait, add a new sigil, rune, a new weapon, an utilitie, or even a mechanic like bufffood every now and then … it keeps the game fresh. With more variety we have a natural development in the meta when it comes to balance. Same like Gw1 was balanced due to so much possibilities to counter the common meta at some points.
*Incentive:
Even more incentive to play would be:
- A titel wich adds up wins in say top50 rated Team Arena matches.
- Something like 1% extra glory for each rank you got so you can unlock things faster.
- A table wich honors the winner of each Monthly Tournament.
Last words:
We need point 3 and 4 I was talking about and we need them fast. Otherwise there is no incentive to activly play as a Team. I can imagine a PvP community getting hyped for that Monthly Tournament wich gets shoutcastet regularly. Anet could even monitor the population and the interest in PvP due to that. If there is no interest at all at this point … i could understand the fact that PvP gets ignored for the reason that there is no profit. If it gets big tho we want to see NA, EU and even Asia compete in Yearly International Tournaments some day. For all the other suggestions I`ve made, I can understand that there are no ressources to do that now. Anyways those points are so important for a casual PvP experience it should be done anytime soon after the core element – competition.
I really hope that you, Anet decides to give PvP a chance. For that chance tho there has to be an investment first.
Sincerley,
the best player EU :-)