Holiday Event Cycles?!
Personally, I’ve always been a fan of rarity and being unique. I too like to collect, and part of being a collector is knowing you have something no one else does. That joy of hearing a person say, “OMG that’s so cool! Where’d you get it?” …. “Wintersday 2012” You’ll reply.
I’d hope they didn’t recycle events so that you can get the things you “missed”. I get that people have lives and other responsibilities … but that’s how life is. Taking part of something that only happens once and having something to show for it is much more valuable then something that is repetitive and achievable all the time.
Also, my favorite part of the Guild Wars 2 genetic makeup is the concept of “choices”. You make a choice and your character evolves from those choices which makes your experience different and unique from others. Items should be the same way. I’d like to accomplish a boss event, or a jump puzzle, or whatever, and pick 1 prize from perhaps 3. Meanwhile my friend may pick a completely different prize from the set. It’s an award of accomplishment, and a trophy that is unique to me that I can feel others wont have.
Again, I understand the “completionist” mentality … but for me, it’s a much better experience for me when I feel I’ve accomplished and found things that most other people haven’t simply because I chose a different path.
And years from now, those Veteran players will have all this cool stuff that the newbies will not … and if I were one of those Veteran’s, I’d feel a much more accomplished collector because of it.
I’m almost certain that Mad King Thorn/Tixx will return next year. Whether or not they’ll offer the same skins/miniatures is anybody’s guess, but I’ll just say that ANet would be missing out on a good opportunity to earn more money by selling the old miniatures/skins to players who missed out last time.