Guild Wars 2

I’d like to know what is the % of chance to get it, I currently have opened about 1000 personalized Trick-or-treat bags and still not got one… One of the guy in my guild got it after 200 bags and someone in the chat got it at his tenth bag. I’ve also seen on the forum someone who opened more than 10 000 and still nothing. So the chance seem really random.

chances are always random. Even with a 50% chance, theres a chance you wont get one in 10k tries.

Just opened 1250 more and nothing…

Not just personalized ones drop the tonic…. just so you know. Easier to farm normal ones then the personalized (for me anyway).

you will probably get one when you stop trying to get one. that is how the world works.

No but seriously it’s just luck.

I open’d roughly 500 personal ToT bags to get mine, I tried 500 normal aswell with no such luck, not a conclusive test but it may lean more towards a higher % chance from personalized.

Yeah personalized have higher chance. But still it seems like nobody know the % of chance.

I got mine after opening 10 personalized bags. I don’t care for it though, I’d much rather have the endless tree tonic, seems stupid that it’s account bound.

That’s what i don’t understand, so many people get it super easely, I saw over 20 people saying they got it super easely, but why is it so rare for some people !

Close to 7-7.5k pToT’s and from 21g to 3g. I’m so invested i just cant stop. So frustrating though. I wish they would let me combine my 250 of each of the 4 tonics to make it =(.

I’ve opened about 5000 so far and haven’t gotten one yet. Someone in my guild opened 17000 before he got it.

Why would anyone even want the stupid tonic?

I have opened at least 15,000 Regular ToT Bags. In addition to that, I’ve opened at least 5,000 pToT Bags. I haven’t got a single Endless Tonic. That was the whole reason I was dumping money into to Bags and Candy Corn in the first place! But after spending 20+ gold, I believe that the bags don’t even contain the Endless Halloween Tonic anymore.

If I knew it would cost me more than 20gold to get nothing, or even to get the tonic. I never would have done it. However, I’ve seen all of these posts about people who opened like 50, or 300 bags and got the Tonic, and I just think; what the hell? Random number games suck.

TL;DR: I spent 20+ gold on 15k ToT bags and 5k pToT bags and didn’t get a single Endless Tonic.

I got 15 pToTbags from the mad king run. Got and endless tonic on my 15th try while having consumed a pumpkin cookie and having an exotic candy corn amulet equipped. Got a major recipe on my next run and got a rare drop from a mob during the instance. The tonic is the first exotic that ever dropped for me. Judging by the posts here I should consider myself very lucky?

Lets not forget opening n number of bags doesnt equate you getting a increased chance xD every single bag you open is its own % which is low sadly, personally I’m over 3k bags and still nothing, just have to keep trying until we do or the event ends :p

OmniPotentes.4817:

I got 15 pToTbags from the mad king run. Got and endless tonic on my 15th try while having consumed a pumpkin cookie and having an exotic candy corn amulet equipped. Got a major recipe on my next run and got a rare drop from a mob during the instance. The tonic is the first exotic that ever dropped for me. Judging by the posts here I should consider myself very lucky?

I would hate you if I hadn’t gotten a Dusk on my 4th mystic forge try :p this has been a blast of a halloween even if the event isnt related xD

I opened exactly 2478 Personal Trick-or-Treat bags before I got mine. I’d planned for 600, but after I passed that mark, I was so invested in it that I just kept going until I eventually got it.

I was actually afraid that I’d been opening the wrong bags, but every search I did always showed ‘Personal Trick-or-Treat’ so I just kept going and going.

Like I’ve told everyone else who’s been going for this, if you weren’t so invested, I’d say to just stop now. I kind of wish I hadn’t gotten started on it.

Only gives you four forms. Candy Golem, Glow-in-the-Dark Skeleton, Plastic Spider, and Mummy. I thought there’d be more forms for the rarity of it, but that’s all that was in it.

Kind of wish I could turn it into a ‘normal’ endless tonic as well. It could be fun just randomly turning into a Candy Golem sometime next June or July, though.

Then again, I have so many of the temporary Halloween potions that I didn’t even NEED the Endless one. More than enough to last until next Halloween.

Here’s to hoping more forms get added. I’d love to see them patch in the Spooky Skeleton and Spooky Ghost after they take those items off the gem store.

I opened well over 2000 bags and have yet to get the endless tonic. On the other hand, I did get the Recipe for the Gift of Souls, so at least I made money back and then some. If it is anything like the gift recipes, you just have to be freakishly lucky to get one!