Guild Wars 2

Over 9000 bags opened (no pun intended) and nothing yet. Really close to quitting. To everyone who is still trying to get it, good luck!

I’ve only opened 3000 bags and don’t have a tonic. I can’t complain though. If they weren’t rare, everyone would have them and they would no longer be special.

So can anyone give me the ropes here?

Is it only the PToT or any ToT works? Also you get PToT from the kids right?

Shostie.6435:

I’ve only opened 3000 bags and don’t have a tonic. I can’t complain though. If they weren’t rare, everyone would have them and they would no longer be special.

I agree 100% with you. But, like someone said in a previous post, I believe that there should be a way to reward perseverance, for example, a mystic forge recipe where you would use 250 of each tonics. It would still wouldn’t be easy to obtain.

Nox Aeterna.2965:

So can anyone give me the ropes here?

Is it only the PToT or any ToT works? Also you get PToT from the kids right?

All ToT and PToT bags have a chance at giving you an endless tonic.

I ended up opening around 3000 bags total, formed of approximately 2000 Personalised and 1000 dropped bags.

No endless tonic, but mountains of the finite versions. I suppose there are enough of them that I’m unlikely to run out.

Yeah luck is a crazy thing…

Did 200th MK dungeons runs,Not one unique skin
1500 bags no tonic or even a superior recipe

Open 5 BLC get a endless mysteric tonic that make you become random trees…

That luck for ya.

Opened about 2k for mine.

Opened 30,000 bags. No tonic. Sigh…

Yeah, I’ve spent 30g+ on pToT/ToT Bags. I have no Endless Halloween Tonic. What I do have, is 500 of each of the four other tonics you get. (Halloween, Concentrating, Spider, and Candy Corn).

In another thread, somebody who has been just as unlucky as I am suggested that there be a mystic forge recipe that puts a stack of each of those four tonics in and you get the Endless Halloween Tonic out. That would be totally awesome. You need to open like 10k bags to get a stack of each anyway.

However, we all know ANet won’t implement this totally fair thing into the game for people like me getting screwed by the RNG.

I think I have it. I didn’t get it from the bags though.
I got a key while doing story for my sub characters and got it from BLC.
I didn’t know what it meant by replenishing. Does it means I can use it unlimitedly?

My Endless Mystery Tonic is fun but I’m not sure it was worth the cost of even one Black Lion Key, let alone 9000 or something.

GregT.4702:

My Endless Mystery Tonic is fun but I’m not sure it was worth the cost of even one Black Lion Key, let alone 9000 or something.

If you don’t think it’s worth it, then your missing the point all together of what a tonic is/does. Oh and the endless mystery tonic is completely different from the endless Halloween tonic.

Got my endless halloween tonic after maybe 200 bags.

and this is why i just bought the mad king costume instead :P still no tonic.. but eh i got jokes from the king baby.

Gave away all my candy to the cute ghost yesterday, opened about 1000 bags: no tonic, but the recipes for the exotic rune and sigil among masses of food, rotten eggs and toilet paper that i will be happily throwing onto our opponents in wvw.

Afterwards did “Mad King says” for 3-4 times, got my hat, opened the bags: tadaaa, endless halloween tonic