I think you did a good job with the rewards for the shadow of the mad king!…however,.for this event, the commendations rewards aren’t so great.
The black lion key is nice but for those people who dont want to save up a lot of commendations theres nothing worthwhile and TBH im not sure if even that is worth it. The Gathering Tools arent that great because its better to simply buy them from the merchants. I would rather have consumables for cheap commendations rewards or crafting mats.
The rewards for the scavenger hunts are good solid rewards through! I dont know if there will be other commendations rewards offered later once we have access to the new map,but so far the commendatiosn rewards arent that great.