Guild Wars 2

I recently completed the level 73 Personal Story quest, Through the Looking Glass and I am extremely disappointed. When Trahearne was introduced at Claw Island my character recognized him, something I deeply enjoyed. But now when Carys and Tegwen were involved, they had no idea who my character was despite having completed the story quests they were in back in the Sylvari starting zone. This ruined the enchantment of the Personal Story quest line for me.

So riddle me this, why were the personal stories made if characters only have a 50/50 chance at remembering who your character is? I understand it takes a lot of time and effort to create these scenes but a quick exchange of dialogue recognizing a character goes a long way, as it happened with Trahearne.

You must have missed the part where Trahearne actually didn’t know you, nor did the Pale Tree.

A discussion is here

Same happened to me…really disturbed me

It is not just you. There have been at least 5 threads either on this topic or that mentioned this topic along with other plot hole. A lot of people were put off by this.