Guild Wars 2

So how about making an 8 players dungeon where every class is needed to complete the dungeon. Make each class unique that some skills from each profession are keys in completing the dungeon (portals) (RTL) (banners, for pressure plate maybe :P) (Feedback) (Pets) etc.

The purpose of removing the typical trinity from the game was to negate people from sitting around for hours trying to find someone of a specific profession and level to party with. This would cause that issue so there is no way they would consider it I’m afraid.

I think a dungeon which needed every class would not be good since it would complicate the group play again.

But I fully agree that you should be able do have bigger groups for dungeons… I don’t know how hard it would be to implement but since there is allready scaling in the open world perhaps dungeons could scale in between 5-9 players. That would be a great addition in my opinion since then you could really sometimes do a dungeon with all your friends / guildmates without someone left out since it happens quite often that you are not exactly 5 / 10 / etc people and of course you can just take randoms but once in a while just playing an evening with friends where you don’t have to rely on strangers for having fun would be nice.