Progression is something that’s come up quite a bit since the Lost Shores update, with most of the discussion focused on stat progression and ascended items. It was the idea of cosmetic progression however that first drew me to this game, and it’s an idea I’d like to see further developed. I firmly believe that cosmetic progression is a viable alternative to stat progression—just not in its current implementation.
Currently, cosmetic progression takes the form of obtaining new items with unique looks, either to keep or transmute. There are problems with this system—
- Harder-to-get items are not always as desirable as readily-available ones, depending on personal taste.
- New looks will entirely replace old ones, rather than improving upon them.
- Once obtained, there is little room for improving cosmetics beyond dyeing them.
My suggestion is that items of all tiers and appearance have some sort of inherent cosmetic progression to them. I think this is best illustrated with examples—
As a weapon example, take the sylvari t2 focus, which is a blue flower. There are one or two similar skins in the game, but for the most part there is no progression once you obtain this focus and decide you like the look. My idea is that the appearance of this focus is something that could constantly be improved upon. Perhaps with a bit of work its appearance could be upgraded or taken along different paths. Maybe you’d like it to be a rose instead? Or a nightblooming flower? Or have it glow in the dark? A static skin that you like would then become something that could grow along with your character.
As an armor example, take the “country” light armor. It’s an early model of armor that I think many people pass over. Now suppose there are several cosmetic upgrades you could get for it. A flower on the lapel? A different style of leggings? Extra dye slots for more customization freedom? Cufflinks, a scarf, or simply different patterns on the fabric?
I think a system like this would add new life to the game, with characters able to obtain more unique and satisfying appearances by exploring content.