Garden of eden - for crafters by crafters
I get what you mean, but I’m not so sure this is in the scope of the game. Gathering is important for crafting, but it’s not a main part of the game, so I think the way it is now accomplishes its purpose.
The way I could see this working, is adding this in addition to normal gathering. Not replacing it. So you can still go out and harvest things in one click (current system), but add your system for players that want to do that as well (could be in your home area in cities). A small farm.
That way could work without simply revamping all the gathering system and pulling the rug from under a lot of people… I’m not sure I would use that system, but at least it would not interfere with the current game.