Guild Wars 2

PROBLEM:

1) Having players thet are not even on the same server in the same guild, kind of defeats the purpose of WvWvW. Guilds are sup post to be “a group of people with similar interests” and with this system, you’re pitting guild members against each other. Also, players on different servers can’t group together, so why even bother guilding together.

SOLUTION:

Tell players they have a limited time to select there permanent server home. once the deadline is up, add a charge for players to move servers, and remove players from guilds that are not on the home server of the guilds leader.

PROBLEM:

2) Allowing players to join multiple guilds with a single character is kinda dumb in my oppinion. I can see allowing players to join multiple guilds with multiple charactes, but not multiple guilds with one toon. If a player is unsure of what he wants with a guild, he/she shouldn’t join a guild in the first place.

SOLUTION:

Again, announce to players that they have a limited time to select a single guild, if players fail to meet this deadline, remove them from all guilds and have them join a single guild after the given time.

PROBLEM:

3) Offline players, at this point there is no way to show if guild members are inactive for long periods. players what to join active guilds, and guild with multiple players that are inactive are decieveing to newer players.

SOLUTION:

Simple enough, add an offline timer.

These problems and solutions are only my oppinion. I believe the guild system in this game has alot of downsides in maintaning active players who want to help guilds grow. I know they are trying to limit the amount of guild in this game unlike most games that have 500 million guilds.

Sorry for the name change, I thought this would me better for the idea i was trying to press.

1) I’m not too opposed to this issue. Some guilds like to span multiple servers, so let them. You don’t have to have players from other servers in your guild if you don’t want to.

2) I agree with you 100% on this point, but unfortunately this feature is here to stay because a lot of players support it.

3) Yes, I hope this is a feature that Arenanet is planning to implement soon. I don’t like how little focus there has been on guild improvements since launch.

Players only support these issues, because they are not guild leaders. If each player made there own guild, they would see that half there players are not even supporting (representing) the guild, and others you can’t even play with because they are on a completely different server, or they have 200 people in there guild and nobody is ever on, then maybe they would realize that these options are dumb and should be removed, and how frustrating this would be for someone who is attempting to maintain an active guild of players with similar interests. ALSO, WoW just released MoP a couple days ago, so alot of players are leaving to go play that stupid game and may never return. That being said, guild leaders need to be able to see when a players last play date was so they can be delt with effectively.