Joining more guilds...
I don’t understand how your suggestion makes things better. If all characters are always representing all guilds, how does the game determine which chat to use? Which guild gets the influence for completing events? Which guild provides benefits during PvE or WvW?
My guild (and the others to which I belong) are happy to have members that only sometimes represent the guild. People can easily join our group activities when there’s nothing going on with their guild, but they can just as easily switch back to their default.
On the other hand, I can see how some guilds (particularly ones approaching 500 members) would want to know who represents 80% of the time versus who represents 20% versus those players who are rarely online at all. I agree that the guild structure could use help in this area.
John Smith: “you should kill monsters, because killing monsters is awesome.”
I partially agree with the topic starter.
At the moment, I’m getting fed up with people joining my guild and then representing another, until they get invited to do a dungeon run. This is not the way a guild should work.
People in a guild should all be working together to make the guild great, not switching around whenever it suits them. That totally defeats the purpose of a guild, now players are just switching around to benefit themselves as much as possible, letting other players work for their benefits.
I’d love to have one-guild-per-character functionality. Get one character to join this guild, another in that guild etc. But if you want to join a new guild, you have to leave your other guild first.
If you want to play with another guild, no problem, but being part of a guild shouldn’t be taken as lightly as it is now.
Dastor i agree, people join my guild just to run dungeons with us and thats the only time they rep, but am not going to go though and whisper each member who isn’t repping to see if they wanna run a dungeon, if they don’t rep they miss out. I don’t see what was wrong with old gw1 alliance
I disagree and agree. you make a good point but i also like the idea of being in more than 1 guild.
https://forum-en.gw2archive.eu/forum/game/suggestions/Guild-Wars-2-Should-Have-Guild-Wars/first#post1094155
The last time someone fought me… lets just say, eating oatmeal is too tough on their teeth.
Really Cosplay this is the third thread you have done this on shamelessly promoting your thread on other peoples threads that have nothing to do with your’s. This is an action that is not allowed in the GW forums
The idea of joining multiple guilds is hindered by the fact that you can only talk to one guild at a time. I can’t really practically be in a small, friend-based guild and be in a bigger guild to do more content with at the same time.