Guild Wars 2

I made a post about this in the Halloween thread regarding the Endless Halloween tonics, and many people agreed with my stance so I figured I’d share it here as a suggestion. (I will write this with the halloween tonic as an example)

The major problem with having account bound endless tonics is that people can be grouped into two groups. Some people REALLY want to have it, while the other kind really don’t care for it at all, and will leave it unused forever.

To get one you have to be extremely lucky. There is no way to craft one, so you have to rely on chance. This means that someone who desperately wants one might go through 1000s of chests/bags to get one, while someone who don’t care for it might get it in their first bag.
This leaves us with one batch of players that really really want an endless tonic, but cannot get it, and one batch that has it, but don’t really want it.

The solution is easy, make them sellable. This is how it worked in GW1, and it made everyone happy. Those who really wanted it but didn’t wanna take a chance could simply buy it from someone who got lucky but didnt want it. It truly satisfies both parties.

I’m probably repeating myself a bit, but the solution really is easy and I can’t find a good reasons as to why they are bound to your account at the moment. It worked like this in GW1 without any complications, so to me it just makes sense to change this very minor, but important function.

I’ve spent 10g plus around 5000 candy corn looking for the endless.

Support.