Currently @ some T1 server in EU
Racial stat bonuses
Currently @ some T1 server in EU
ANet does not want it so that race X is better than race Y or that you have some sort of advantage over others. Their solution was the racials we have now. Which are a bit underwhelming, but the idea is good.
I’m afraid that your suggestion would not work, I don’t agree with it and it is too late to change it now.
No thanks, this along with other racial bonus suggestions I’ve seen (such as Norn/Charr have a speed bonus because they are bigger/have longer legs). This would make people who want to min/max pigeon-holed into certain race-class combos. Also how would you even “balance” this? How much +boon duration is equivalent to extra power or extra crit damage.
If you made the stat increases noticeable this would happen immediately (and also everyone would complain that the race-class combo they have is now bad and they have to relevel a new character). People are willing to spend a lot of money to just get infusions that give +5AR and +5 stat (or some get ascended gear also for the infusion stat bonuses), and exotic back pieces give more than +5 to a single stat. Do you really want to see, “LFM Charr War only”
The immersion comes from the skins/environment/RP, not from stat bonuses. If you want another example where it “fails” just look at DnD. A very balanced approach if I say, but how many half-orc bards do you see (and yes the ones I’ve seen are very funny/great)? But, you only see them if someone wants to play against the norm or make something for “fun” (without being useful).