Guild Wars 2

Alright I’m a newish guild leader in GW2 and mostly I love guilds and how they work. The upgrades are fun and gives incentive to get influence and the represent mechanic is great as well. Though there are two things I have issues with.
Admin Lower Ranks. Say I want people to be able to invite people to the guild, but not promote/kick? If I give it to someone they have the potentional to ruin a guild due to the fact they can kick anyone their rank or lower. I’d like to allow people to invite but NOT allow them to kick or promote, Let’s refine it abit.
My second gripe is the guild bank. I know some people might not want to hear this but WoW has a better guild banking system. I’d like to be able to seperate tabs and choose what rank can grab from what tab. Say I want to put gold in the guild bank for guild purposes but my member rank above new member allows for guild withdraws? Why not change it to “Allow member to withdraw gold?” “Allow member to withdraw rare quality items?” and so forth. Though these might be minor gripes it can derail the enjoyment of being a guild leader when you have to worry about people making rather unwanted actions.

Sincerely,
CombatTacos.

CombatTacos.8706:

Admin Lower Ranks. Say I want people to be able to invite people to the guild, but not promote/kick? If I give it to someone they have the potentional to ruin a guild due to the fact they can kick anyone their rank or lower. I’d like to allow people to invite but NOT allow them to kick or promote.

Sounds reasonable, and gives guild lots of flexibility. There are many changes they can add to guilds. Love to see a guild commander upgrade. Basically a commander and squad system that works like the 100gp one, but it’s only visible to people in your guild and uses guild influence to get.

Can’t you create a new rank for your recuiters and then place them at the bottom of the rank listing? He will be able to recruit, but with new members being assigned the rank above him, no further personnel administration is possible.

ancient highway.4256:

Can’t you create a new rank for your recuiters and then place them at the bottom of the rank listing? He will be able to recruit, but with new members being assigned the rank above him, no further personnel administration is possible.

It does allow that. But it’d be easier to separate promote/kick and invite.

I agree with separating promote/kick (it was closer to that during BETA, but, for a variety of good reasons, it got changed). Some people are good at recruiting, but terrible at figuring out who to promote (and vice-versa). In at least some guilds, you might want anyone to be able to invite a new member to join as a recruit (no permissions), but only allow officers promote recruits to member (with basic permissions).

You can already separate permissions for the shared bank: the top tab (and coin) uses one set; the bottom two tabs (and coin) uses another. I wouldn’t mind more layers of nuance, but there are other guild issues/suggestions I’d like to see addressed first.