sPVP tournament balance - suggestions

sPVP tournament balance - suggestions

in Suggestions

Posted by: Feyr.7283

Feyr.7283

Hi,

Could we get some improvements in terms of team balance for sPVP tournaments, please?

As you can see in the screenshot, the average level of Blue is about twice as high as Red’s, plus there’s 6 Mesmers in this match, four of them alongside necro me.

A game which is “balanced around teamplay” should surely have equal teams and a healthy mix of professions in each team?

(I’m not even complaining that I was 32 levels below the lowest level player of the other team in this match, although that can’t be right either.)

This was NOT a one-off sort of match setup. I’ve seen this happening often on my other account (and different server) too. This particular screenshot is just showing off all those balancing problems in one go very nicely.

TL;DR version: How about making up teams that cannot have more than two players of the same profession? And how about roughly equal levels?

(edit: reordered and TL;DR highlighted)

Attachments:

(edited by Feyr.7283)

sPVP tournament balance - suggestions

in Suggestions

Posted by: Robin Skyshroud.1863

Robin Skyshroud.1863

I agree with Feyr, high rank/glory can often tell the other players how “seasoned” the fighter is. Going up against someone of higher rank would obviously show and result in the person having played more and thus learned a great deal regarding the do’s and donts, and the ins and outs of combat.

Now, if i was not me and responded in someone else’s way of thinking, that “me” would say, rank/glory can do nothing to the player’s skill level. Rank/glory is only there for fancier looking weapons and armor. All the stats on gear are balanced and are intended for fair competition. Then quite often, ending it with the word “noob”.
(haha its actually funny and wierd how people do sound like that)

sPVP tournament balance - suggestions

in Suggestions

Posted by: daydream.2938

daydream.2938

Its based of win/loss not rank. But what can happen is high ranked players can lose some high ranked match, some low ranked players can win some low ranked matchs, they meet in the middle but are not equilevant, and it aint pretty.

sPVP tournament balance - suggestions

in Suggestions

Posted by: Feyr.7283

Feyr.7283

I should point out that my main suggestion really is a profession balance. 4 Mesmers in a team of 5? That invalidates the whole “balanced around teamplay”.

The other part (being ranks) is obviously a lot more difficult to “fix”. I coped okay in all matches with players that seemed to have a lot more experience, but only because my other account has a higher ranking than the one I provided the screenshot of. If I was really only level 5 (that can be done in a few hours and a bit of luck without any skill whatsoever), it would be a different story.

A developer could probably point out how this new balance system actually works. It can’t be ranks, and it can’t be profession-based either, or else we’d never see screenshots of matches like this one.