ASK/BID priority

ASK/BID priority

in Black Lion Trading Co

Posted by: Psychol.5783

Psychol.5783

1. Who will receive first item if there are a multiple offers for the same price?
2. Who will sell first item if there are multiple items for the same price?

In my experience my offer for the same price placed 2 days ago was filled faster than an offer placed 3 days ago and offer placed 5 days ago.

ASK/BID priority

in Black Lion Trading Co

Posted by: Leablo.2651

Leablo.2651

First come first serve. If you say otherwise, what do you base that on?

ASK/BID priority

in Black Lion Trading Co

Posted by: John Smith.4610

John Smith.4610

When at the same price orders are FIFO

ASK/BID priority

in Black Lion Trading Co

Posted by: rodadams.5963

rodadams.5963

When at the same price orders are FIFO

I’ll dispute this to some degree.

Earlier this week, I put in buy orders for 10 stacks of 250 for taffy, all at 4c, in the span of a couple minutes.

A couple days ago, eight of those stacks filled completely, and both of the remaining two were partially filled. Several days later, I still have buy orders in for 242 and 208 taffy.

If it was proper FIFO, then there’d be no way that the later stack would be touched before the first stack was consumed. Also, it appears that somehow, both of these orders got pushed to the bottom of the queue, since there’s been quite some delay in them being filled.

(You should be able to see my transaction history.)

ASK/BID priority

in Black Lion Trading Co

Posted by: Caittus.7436

Caittus.7436

Maybe a partial fill sets a stack to the back of the line?

ASK/BID priority

in Black Lion Trading Co

Posted by: rodadams.5963

rodadams.5963

Maybe a partial fill sets a stack to the back of the line?

That wouldn’t make sense, because when the other 8 orders for 250 filled, they appeared in the pickup window as several pages worth of piles of taffy of all different sizes, suggesting they were fulfilled by many different steps of partial fulfillment.

What it does sound like though, is that in some situations, partial fulfillment sends an order to the back of the queue, and in others it doesn’t. I have nowhere near enough insight to determine what conditions set this off.
Hopefully Mr Smith and/or his collegues have sufficient tracking to figure this out.

(edited by rodadams.5963)

ASK/BID priority

in Black Lion Trading Co

Posted by: Smooth Penguin.5294

Smooth Penguin.5294

Or perhaps with thousands of players in this game using the BLTP at any given time, someone posted the exact same Buy Order as you, albeit a few miliseconds quicker.

And not all orders are filled as exact stacks of 250. If someone sold 76 to you, that’s what you get in your pickup window.

In GW2, Trading Post plays you!