Guild Wars 2

Which dungeon, in your opinion, is the hardest, roughest, most challenging and most hated for how unfair/impossible it feels?

All of them because they have too much HP. I wonder if I can kill this boss first before I die of old age.

That’s a hard one I wouldn’t say specific dungeons are hardest but specific paths or encounters. The two highest level dungeons have the most unforgiving mechanics such as Crucible of Eternity and Arah. However some of the other dungeons have hair pulling encounters as well.

Edit: Also it depends a lot on the party you are with, how skilled they are and teamwork. It also varies depending on professions in the party. Some professions make for certain encounters to be easier but then others are harder.

i think if you take them as whole dungeon experiences (all the paths), CoE has you fighting Subject Alpha like nine times, right?

that said, i’ve never done Arah

Coe, alpha fights.
Arah, expecially path 4.
TA, blossoms can gives you a headache

Arah path 4 and Twilight Arbor blossoms, such a pain.

I found TA to be the hardest dungeon ‘on first go’ however once you get used to it, its possibly one of the easiest.

But given all are pretty easy after a while i would go with TA for that ‘first time’ difficulty and the blossoms etc.

The hardest dungeon EASILY, by FAR, is Arah Exploration Path 1.
Not only do you fight three insanely difficult bosses, the Tar Monster, Giganticus Lupicus AND Korga, but at the end you get the most sorry excuse for a last boss ever. He practically kills himself (if you know what to do).
Tar Monster was manageable. Giganticus Lupicus was a nightmare. And Korga was only defeatable through a glitch that stops him from spawning his stupid 11-second stun monkey minions and makes him run in place like a dumb kitten

TL;DR ARAH EXPLORE PATH 1 NO EXCEPTIONS!!

If you do this dungeon path, you will tear your hair out!
You WILL!

all… the insane hp pools of the mobs are not fun. just extremely tedious. id rather have more trash mobs but with lower hp.

Challenging + Fun = Lupicus Fight
Challenging + High Team work requirements = CoE 3 Lighting Torch part. It requires a lot of team work. Its
Challenging + Hard = CoE 3 “Defend against the 5x waves” + CoF 3 “Defend aginast the 5x waves”

Hardest Dungeon puzzle = TA water springs with swarms of bees.
Challenging but not necessarily hard Dungeon Puzzle = CoE 3 Aoe Fire ball dash with troll turrets at the end;)

Most Challenging Last Dungeon Boss = CoE Subject Alpha (When it doesn’t bug)
Hardest Dungeon Boss = SE 3? or 1? I cant remember. The 2 Golems that need to be killed at the same time.

Most Boring Dungeon Fight = TA last boss’s.

The four Champion level sharks at the end of Honor of the Waves – have yet managed to get all four killed before everyone gives up and leaves. No idea if there is a loot chest down there or not.