Edit: A bunch of people had a much better suggestion to give Ascended items the same stats as exotics, basically only having the infusion slot as the extra perk/dungeon necessity. While it accomplishes the same thing (not making current gear obsolete in the rest of the game), this implementation makes more sense by introducing an “optional” niche grind that only affects dungeons.
The only way for Anet to save face now is to offer free optional upgrades for soulbound exotic gear acquired prior to the patch up to ascended quality.
Many players have had their exotic items for between 2-6 weeks. If you took your time leveling multiple characters and enjoying the early game, it’s likely that you haven’t had a full exotic set for more than a month at this point. It was made clear from the beginning that exotic was the highest quality of gear (stat wise), and once you had a full set you wouldn’t NEED to get anything else. This “endgame” designation for exotic items caused the price to be greatly inflated, both on the trading post and on karma NPCs. Each item costs between 2-6 gold (depending on when it was purchased), and 42K karma for armor. If you have multiple sets of gear, such as solo, dungeon, and WvW sets, AND multiple characters, the overall cost becomes quite high.
Now with ascended items being the new exotics, exotics are basically the new masterwork, making them relatively worthless compared to their previous value. Considering how new the game is and the short amount of time people have had their “best in slot” gear, adding any upgrades at this point without some type of free upgrade or refund is completely unacceptable. Even if it’s just rings, everyone who purchased them on the TP wasted a considerable amount of gold.
For example, I have 2 80s with full exotics and multiple sets. My main has solo PvE, dungeon, and WvW sets of gear, and my alt has a dungeon and WvW set of gear. Together that’s 10 exotic rings. At an average cost of 2.5g, that means I wasted 25 gold in rings alone. That is not an insignificant amount of gold, and if you think it is, put your money where your mouth is and send me some. Had I known that Ascended items were coming and exotics would start becoming obsolete within a couple months, I would have made some very different choices.
MMOs live or die by the confidence players have in the game. Confidence that their character will still be there the next time they log in. Confidence that their achievements, currency, and items won’t randomly change or disappear one day for no reason. Confidence that the knowledge they have acquired won’t suddenly become obsolete with no warning or reason. Do you think World of Warcraft would have become anywhere near as popular if the Tier 1 and 2 raid sets were suddenly replaced by tier 2.5 two months into the game? I think not, and that’s exactly what Anet has done, except to EVERYONE.
Of course not everyone has lost faith in Anet over this choice to introduce a new quality of gear so early in the game, but many have. The 85k view 8k post thread on the general forum proves that this is a controversial issue with many people on both sides. I for one will completely lose confidence in the longevity of GW2 over this if something isn’t done to restore it.
(edited by Valhallen.1693)