Balancing
Note: This is mostly for the math and info. Tiny rant at the beginning and a bigger one at end.
I only have something to say on the burning because I don’t ever play Mesmer and have no idea about it’s OP’ness or how it could be balance if it indeed needs to be balanced. To put it simply, Burning is op compared to other conditions. The following calculations are the damage formulas for every damaging condition as pulled from the official wiki and are calculated with a couple assumptions.
1. Confusion is calculated as if a skill is used every second by the target to keep the damage on the same time.
2. Torment is calculated as if the target is moving.
3. Condition Damage is calculated with a stat of 900 (because it’s the middle pvp stat from the amulets. I needed a number)
4. It is assumed the user is level 80.
Burning – (0.155 * Condition Damage) + (1.55 * Level) + 7.5
(0.155 * 900) + (1.55 * 80) + 7.5 =
(139.5) + (124) + 7.5 = 271
Poison – (0.06 * Condition Damage) + (0.375 * Level) + 3.5
(0.06 * 900) + (0.375 * 80) + 3.5
(54) + (30) + 3.5 = 87.5
Bleeding – (0.06 * Condition Damage) + (0.25 * Level) + 2
(0.06 * 900) + (0.25 * 80) + 2
(54) + (20) + 2 = 76
Confusion – OT(0.035 * Condition Damage) + (0.1 * Level) + 2 // SA(0.0625 * Condition Damage) + (0.575 * Level) + 3.5
OT(0.035 * 900) + (0.1 * 80) + 2 // SA(0.0625 * 900) + (0.575 * 80) + 3.5
OT(31.5) + (8) + 2 = 41.5 // SA(56.25) + (46) + 3.5 = 105.75
(41.5) + (105.75) = 147.25
Torment – (0.045 * Condition Damage) + (0.18 * Level) + 1.5
(0.045 * 900+ (0.18 * 80) + 1.5
(40.5) + (14.4) + 1.5 = 56.4
(56.4) * (2) = 112.8
In case you don’t want to read the math and pull the values, here they are.
Burning = 271 dps per second
Poison = 87.5 dps per stack
Bleeding = 76 dps per stack
Confusion = 147.25 dps per stack
Torment = 112.8 dps per stack
Confusion and Torment which are supposed to be heavily punishing for using skills and moving respectively are about half the damage Burning can do without a gimmick to deal with. The only condition that can potentially match a single stack of burning is Confusion and that is only of the one with confusion is an idiot and spams skills. My point? Burning does MASSIVE damage for little more than stacking a couple on someone and waiting. And don’t use the, “Oh, you can just cleanse it,” argument because that works for every condition. If Immobilize kept you in place for 2 minutes it would be OP, but, Oh, you can just cleanse it…
(edited by ZombieLeach.5862)