Guild Wars 2

Tonics are worthless. You can’t fight in them, and you can’t dye them.

Please turn them into outfits.

I second this!

Yes. I completely agree.

I don’t understand the whole tonic idea at all to begin with…

Tonics work for halos and horns, but townclothes should be outfits.

I don’t understand why town clothes were removed instead of redesigned, personally.

Why not reinvent costume brawl?

Kerithlan.1659:

I don’t understand why town clothes were removed instead of redesigned, personally.

Why not reinvent costume brawl?

Personally I like how many head pieces such as glasses were implemented as actual head battle gear, but the actual clothes should be at least outfits.

Outfits should be individual item skins that can be worn interchangeably with any armor and individually dyed.

Stop thinking small. Stop settling for one bad option over another and take the idea all the way to the solution that would actually please everyone.

I think those tonics really should be made into outfits. I’ll still miss being able to mix-and-match them, but at least we’d be able to dye them again, and they’re a lot more usable than tonics, since they don’t take up inventory space, wear off, or require hunting-for-and-clicking to re-apply them. Town Clothes were sometimes called “useless” before, but even the people who loved Town Clothes seem to consider the tonic versions useless now. It’s a real shame for a feature that, while not widely-loved, was still loved, to go to such waste like this.

That said, I’m not particularly interested in seeing them made into fully interchangeable armor skins for all three weight classes. They weren’t designed for that, and, technical obstacles to making that happen aside, I still think it would be an aesthetic disaster.