Guild Wars 2

In dungeons, you have a chance to get tonics which transforms you into certain creature.
It has no costume-brawl skills and tonics ruins your chance to loot rare gear item.

My questions are:
1) Do you think dungeon tonics are useless/worthless?
2) Why does people buy them on TP?
3) Would you remove them from dungeon loot table/dungeon vendor?
4) Would you buy tonic from dungeon vendor?

1) Do you think dungeon tonics are useless/worthless?
Yes. I don’t think they belong as a dungeon chest reward, as TC has said, it just takes up a slot for a chance at good gear.

2) Why does people buy them on TP?
I don’t think they do; reason being, they are extremely cheap to buy on the TP. This is part of the reason why people dislike them- they can’t even sell them for a decent price.

3) Would you remove them from dungeon loot table/dungeon vendor?
Absolutely, in a heartbeat. Don’t remove them from the game- make them accessible another way, so that people that enjoy them can still access them easily.

4) Would you buy tonic from dungeon vendor?
Use tokens for a tonic? Absolutely not. Ever.

Yes
No Idea. Maybe because they’re dirt cheap and a level 2 could afford them.
Yes
yes

I think it’s pretty steep to buy tonic for 10 tokens if you can buy 1 hour potion with +10% damage outcome and 10% dmg reduction for 1 token.

And i think they ARE completely useless.