Guild Wars 2

Mighty Hammer: Gives fire bear paw prints and has bear and flame decals. A flaming bear paw swipe accompanies the hammer’s swings.

Light slicer: A flamish looking mini lightsaber (so like 90% lightsaber 10% firesword) that alternates between green and lavender with its strikes and while hilted. Footsteps also alternate gradually between green and lavender.

Tiger’s Hammer: Like the mighty hammer but with tiger stripped human footprints and a ghostly tiger’s claw swipes with the hammer (normal orange and black colored tiger but translucent)

Yog Sothoth’s shortbow: Shoots big bolts of black and deep purple energy with a corrupt looking purple trail and like the Lover but with an original monster higher than a dragon with batwings, tentacle face and a fin on its head while still being on four legs but naming stuff is hard so I can’t think of it now in place of a pony. This could be seen as a forshadowing of an event where original creatures higher than dragons could be introduced. The bow itself would have moving Yog Sothoth limbs on a small decal in a way that obviously wouldn’t compromise functionality so like the Lover basically but with a different Lovecraftian theme.

T-Rex sword: Like the above mentioned hammers but with a sword and bites instead of swipes. Makes T-Rex roaring sounds upon landing a critical hit. Lizard T-Rex none of this silly feathered raptor stuff.

Steampunk staff: Has a crystal airship at its end and a brass handle and the user creates smog footsteps. Bifrost like effects but with steam and smog.

Killshot: A sniper rifle that looks like one from modern day real life. User has bloody footprints with holes.

Coming up with ideas can be hard but these just came to me.