we do it in the mmorpg map (not the wvw nor spvp). NOW for a g vs g to start, a war document must be signed, once signed, then the 2 guilds can kill each other if the members are over lvl30 or 40. then the winner takes control over a certain region, and drop rates and rares increase for their guild members in that region (stuff like that). now obviously if the guild is a new guild, then no war can be started, a guild need to have a certain amount of lvl80 members in it including the guild leader.
PK is still NOT going to happen and should remain that way, but guild wars should happen with a very good and fixed set of RULES, so its fun for everybody.
this means we should have guild bases and a guild hall and stuff…..i just truly feel that guilds need to become something in this game….guilds arent important enough in this game….at all. its mostly just for funzies and convenience and stuff, but where is the dedication and real competition.