I dont know how to name the post and it wont be an all negative post because i love gw2 and i care about the game. It will be an all PVE post since i dont really pvp. TL;DR at the end of each section.
1 : No new content.
-After returning i was looking forward to try super adventure box. Alas, it was removed. There is so much neat stuff i tried in guild wars 2 like getting all the crystals in the sky event or doing all the arena at the queen jubilee to test my skills. When i talk about it to my friends, my eyes sparkle (like a vampire) and my friends are really motivated to try this out but i have to make them sad and say its gone… Like the current event im not that much a fan of but the next one might be cool. I would just like more permanent things to be in the game. I can understand events like halloween or christmas to be once a year but super adventure box was one of the best thing ever. I would buy a game if it was stand alone just to show how much i like it. So for me its the #1 problem in guildwars too. I cannot be there always as i have health/school issues and im sad when i miss great events. Except some tweaks to classes, nothing is new in the pve world except ascended weapon (that engi dont benefit on kits). So when you return, except for the current event, everything is still the same, i cannot go and do those crazy southsun race or gather crystal on an alt or whatever
TL;DR : so much content i loved and its gone. Now i come back and the game is mostly the same, nothing new to do except the current live event. Need more permanency.
2 Heavy focus on appearance, lack of tool for it.
I dont know how they want to run their game but its one of the most gorgeous one out here. The art style is incredible, the attacks are flashy and the variety in armors and weapons is OUTSTANDING. Sadly you can only wear one at a time. There is currently 2 armors i want out of the blacklion market, the new heavy armor and the magitech leather. Why dont i purchase them? because i already like the look im wearing and spent time farming for.
This is where the wardrobe system should have been implemented a long time ago. One of my favorite system was Rift.
http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20110512022450/riftwardrobe/images/f/f3/Wardrobe_Tab.png
The square you see at the bottom are wardrobe slots. People will say “yeah but if they do that they lose the sales of the blue crystal to transmog”. I answer that by, they just have to make the new system use it! Let me explain.
So you could start with no wardrobe slots (or one) and pay 400 gems to unlock a new one. Then to socket an item in a wardrobe slot you could use a transmutation (lvl 80) stone. There you go, you now sell wardrobe slot and transmutation stone still sell.
Or you can make a system that everytime you use a transmutation stone on an item, you save the appearance (for the account or the character) in an apperance tab, just like the new system in diablo 3.
http://www.diablowiki.net/images/thumb/4/46/Transmogrify-02.jpg/618px-Transmogrify-02.jpg
So like that people will buy TON of stones to save different sets they like and will be able to mix and match without overcloging their bag.
TL;DR : A game based so much on appearance and have no system of gathering/loot hoarding/and wardrobe system? Something need to be put in place so we can store them and be fashion artist.
3 Dissapearing items from the Blacklion market gems
I remember seeing Rox quiver , a nice shield, a mace and a shortbow? Why are they gone, these were popular items, even all these gathering tools or just the copper fed machine. Do you think by making them rarer people will jump on them next time? No! I mean… I made a new character, i would love to have an unlimited salvage kit… you would have made money right now. Even if you get it out next month, will i still be there. I tend to hop on another mmo when i get bored and since gw2 kinda lack permanency ill probably play the time to get a legendary on a new character then hop again. So even if you repost one of the tradepost in the mean time ill be gone and wont follow “gw2 news” and log specifically to buy one. I buy if its there and its not, i skip.
So far i would have bought (if the system were in place in #2)
-1x magitech armor
-1x new heavy armor
-1x rox quiver (again, i got one on my ranger)
-1x rox shortbow
-1x the shield of the norn
-1x copper fed salvage machine
-1x infinite mining pick
-1x infinite axe
the herb gatherer is there.
So how much money is that? Im pretty sure im not the only one who would be willing to buy some stuff but dont because its A) not there or already like their look and dont see the point in buying a second good looking armor when the one they wear is free.
TL;DR : Stop taking items away from the Blacklion gem store. I wanna buy them now, i dont know where ill be next month, make the sale now.