[Suggestion] GW1 for Gems? & price confusion
The game is always going to be buy-to-play, because there are no subscription fees. As long as that’s true, there’s no chance they’ll sell it for just gems (which can be obtained via in-game gold).
Many of us wonder why a 10-year-old game is still selling for the same retail prices it did when GW2 launched. It doesn’t seem crazy to expect to spend less these days.
The reason for the confusion is that there remain a lot of boxed copies of the game in versions sold when the various bundle options were ‘new’ and made sense. These days, one would typically buy Platinum (‘Proph+EotN’) and ‘Trilogy’ (Proph + Factions + NF), to collect the full set.
In your case, there aren’t any great options, since I don’t remember a package of “Factions + EotN”, which would be ideal for you.
If your budget is limited, I’d look for deals on Amazon, BestBuy, Steam, or similar legit sites. If you want to stick to the official site, I’d buy just Platinum to get EotN for $20. That gets you access to the Hall of Monuments (allowing you to link accounts and eventually earn AP/skins in GW2 via GW1 accomplishments). If you run out of stuff to do for fun, then also buy Trilogy to get Nightfall.