Guild Wars 2

like the Title reads. MMOs have lots of room to grow. i see people that come onto the forum to give constructive criticism or give suggestion on how to better the game. some good,some bad. but there’s always that one person that thinks the game is perfect as it is. they don’t go into detail on why said idea/feedback shouldn’t be implemented/fixed. all they say is “The MMO is fine as it is”.

you think WoW started with all those features it has? no. people discussed and gave ideas. “hey wouldn’t it be cool if we could have X?” or “this MMO would benefit is we could do Y.”

some of you people give me Deja vu. you guys remind me of the SWtor forums. people were so blinded to see the MMO was missing key features and would benefit from some new ones. but lots of people would just down shot ideas. with comments like " It’s a Feature" or “the game is fine as it is”," “if that MMO has that feature,why don’t you go and play it?”. i asked for a refund 1 week after release. i saw that MMO and community going nowhere.

this is an MMO. nothing is set in stone.if someone comes with a suggestion on how to grow or be better. they’re not telling you the game is bad.there’s no need to be over protective. it would be better to explain why it’s not a good idea. saying " the game is fine as it is",is not a solid answer.discuss and go into details on why you think it’s not a good idea.

the devs need feedback from everything.

Yeah, it just needs a bigger pot.

U have ur opinion , and they have their opinion :P
No1 is wrong or right :P

Ppl must understand , that atm there are 50-200 ppl posting in here (good or bad ppl)
First of all we must create athread without using moronic words like <<if they dont implant xxx-this- xxx the game will die>>

Personaly when i see these time of threads i kittenstorm them , instead of helping them :P
While if i see contructive ones , my hate transform into <<find a way to help them>>
I really hate arenas or CTF modes , they dont belong in this game without healers , but i have made some suggestions for the both of them in the past , if the thread inspire me :P

U cant <<force>> the devs to implant something , just by forcing the 200 to agree with u and then force the devs :P

Make a thread , even if all the internet is against u , ur message shall be heard :P
Dont care if they agree or not with you

Problem with alot of suggestions I have been reading is: they want to change the core of the game… it’s soul if you will.

This game is very different from the cookie cutter WoW clones. Most of the community want to keep it that way. WoW had a good thing going till they kitten it up, buy bowing to every little gripe and whine. Can you say Easy Button Spam Mode? All ready you have people complaining that things are too hard to get. Heaven forbid a person has to earn their reward.

I am not saying the game could not use improvments. We all know there are some things that need fixing and some things that don’t mesh quite right. For instance waypoint pricing… should be priced for distance, not level. That makes no sense to me.

Another thing that makes no sense is some things that I keep hearing, like trying to bring back the “Unholy Trinity”. I mean seriously, we all knew from the begining, that system was not going to be in here at all. That is the core of the game. In order to change it, the game would have to go all the way back to concept/design/formula.

Its things like this that people fanboy rage about. Trying to change the core design into something it’s not ment to be. These type of people need to realize that it’s not the game for them. Sorry but you are out 60 bucks. Yes it sux. Have droped money plenty of times on a game that just wasn’t for me.

Constructive criticism with multiple solutions is a great thing… if it’s viable. Problem with the threads on these forums is, if something they want isn’t in the game they rage about it. The “Give Me Now Entitlist” generation.

They don’t seem to realize that any siginifant change in the game will not come now. It’s only been 3 weeks. Bug fixes are much more important. They expect the game to be as polished as one that has been on the market for years. This in my opnion is unreasonable. So yes they should get stupid answers for their stupid posts. When you throw a tantrum on a forum, you should expect to be treated in kind.

Disclaimer: I am not saying the OP is the problem. I am speaking about gamers in general on the forums.

Devs really do care about constructive criticism ..i even has some counter-constructive posts deleted to some negative criticism

..only problem is what starts as a constructive criticism turns into counter-constructive negativity