Guild Wars 2

Love the new guild system, and the upgrades, however I think there is just one more rank rule that I think would help.

“Can use general Guild hall Upgrades”

A pretty simple one. Reason for it: I don’t know about other guild halls, but in our one there are a lot of “free riders” people that like to use the guild hall and the big benefits that come with it, like merchant NPC, repair and personal bank via scribe upgrade. But they contribute 0 to the guild in resources/help. With this rule we could move people into a rank, that have been seen to help with the creation of the guild, and so get rewarded for it.

It may also motivate others that don’t help, and wait to use the benefits that a guild hall can bring, into helping.

i think thats a terrible idea
if you need to punish people in this way to get them to contribute then perhaps your guild isnt so guild like after all

It’s not a punishment, it’s a reward. Some people are just selfish and like to let others do the work, they can’t help it. This rule might help them in becoming better people.

It’s no different to real life, VIP passes and so on. it’s just another tool for guilds, they don’t have to use it.

why don’t you just kick the useless ones? if they don’t help and think only for themselves, why should they remain in your guild?

Now the new measuring stick to judge who is a good guildy and who is bad is now not how much you play but how much you PAY. No thanks.