QoL improvements for guild hall upgrades
1. A queue would be nice. Then the whole guild would be able to see which upgrade has priority.
2. Highlight would be very helpful as well, for the same reason as the queue.
3. It would be super to disable/enable certain donations, or even re-arrange their prominence among the donations. As with your suggestion, my guild isn’t big on WvW and those donations aren’t important to us unless necessary for other unlocks.
I don’t feel it’s necessary to jump ahead to donations not-yet-unlocked. That could be overwhelming.
4. I think your “loaning” idea is unnecessarily complicated. You could always put “extras” in the guild bank or ask you guild to keep stacking up elder wood planks, even if the donations are temporarily full, because everyone knows you will continue to need more.
Scribe, on the other hand, is a different can of worms and donations entirely. Maybe a scribe-specific donation center at the workstation would be useful, but… scribe is in a terrible state currently. I scribe for my guild, but making a personal progression guild-fed isn’t going over well among the player base— even if all of your scribe crafts go directly to the guild. There are many concerns about the scribe craft not being guild-bound and until some of this settles out, I can’t agree with the guild feeding donations to a scribe the same way they donate to the guild, even if it’s cripplingly expensive for one person.
Agree with 1, 2, 3.
NSP | Os Guild Master
www.osguild.org | www.youtube.com/osthink