Guild Wars 2

I would like to make a good suggestion how to fix The problem with expensive guildhalls and unlocks.

Guild leader deside how many members The guild gonna havr, lets say 10 max. And there should br some stages, like 10,25,50,100,150 etc. And make The prices for upgrades and stuff be reduced for The 10 man guild. And if you want more people, you have to pay a fee depending how much u have unlocked etc. To match The price for 25 man. So those small guilds have the oppertunity to have a guild at all.

I dont think you should make a lower guild size then 10, even tho you maybe are 2-3. Should be harder if you are a small sized guild. I really hope this will be implanted.

Suggestions?

Price scaling per person would be a nice option. Though it would be simple for members of a guild to leave temporarily to reduce cost, then rejoin later. So this would benefit the larger guilds far more than small guilds. As it is right now, the pricing is simply obscene to unrealistic for small guilds. Only small guilds with heavy traders or fat wallets could afford them within a reasonable time frame. Reasonable for me is finishing the upgrades in under a year.

I think u missunderstand. You have a player limit in The guild. Lets say 10people guild is free. 25 cost X and 50 cost X2. Dunno how much The upgrades cost but. Lets say a guild 150people is price of 15000g (100g each) for full upgrades. If you deside The guild to be 10man. (Then u can only have 10 in the guild) The cost is 1000g. IF u deside TP invite more people and u already upgraded. Lets say from 10-25. Then u have to pay a fee for 1500g. Before u can upgraded to 25man guild. That way it’s the same price for everyone..

It can also be that it should be more expensive for smäller guild like 150g each or so.

Make note that The price are not reality.

The guild hall pricing is fine as it is. My small guild is doing fine with the upgrades in the hall. We tend to have 5-8 people regularly donating to treasury. 2-3 of them with substantial amounts. And none was bought with IRL money.
Your suggestion would be open for abusing by big guilds. Or guilds who didn’t want to/couldn’t afford the gold for simply expanding their guild will never grow. Imagine inviting a new guilds to be met with a Guild message “your hall is too small, the treasury requires 1500g to enable all services again”. Nope. Really silly idea. That would definitely kill small guilds who are actually building a Guild hall rather quickly, doing absolutely fine with this system already.

lol.. i thought someone started selling guild already….

How would you abuse it with a large guild? Also if you want a bigger guild you just put in The money needed from The new players? So price is The same no matter IF u are 10 or 150

Klangy.8293:

How would you abuse it with a large guild? Also if you want a bigger guild you just put in The money needed from The new players? So price is The same no matter IF u are 10 or 150

The price is the same for guilds as it is. The gold/favor needed, the materials is the same right now. Monetizing more of it defeats the object of the whole treasurey system.
As I said, There’s already small guilds doing fine with the current system.
And I wouldn’t want any of them basically taxed by expanding their roster past 10/25 etc members. Say you have a Guild with 24 people then you get taxed Xg for adding one more because you entered a 25-50 bracket. How would a Guild leader manage that “hey guys I know you all donate what you can but now I need 25g off all of you to accomodate the new guy”
What happens to that tax when your roster shrinks? Do we get it refunded?

azizul.8469:

lol.. i thought someone started selling guild already….

That’s actually a treat idea. Get hundreds of people to build you a guild using tens of thousands of gold worth of resources, then kick them all and sell it.

I wonder how many weeks before this happens. The kitten storm on these forums is going to be glorious.

Well u can also make it individual per person. Lets say i have 100% i invitrin a personto my 1person guild. Now The guild is 50% complete. Now he The member needs to chip in. If not i simply kick him. If i invite 2 members with 50% each i get total of 75% complete in The guild and so on. There is alot of different ways to keep The guild cost as cheap or expensive no matter if u are 5 or 150 man.