Guild Wars 2

Anyone else think that they are over overexploiting the subject?

I mean Caithe took the egg for the right reasons, she didnt trust the PC and she had their resasons (she was the only one knowing what silvarys were and how Mordremoths was coming). She could not risk the egg to end on mordry’s hands.

But most important, she killed faolin with us, her own lover, she apologize several times during HoT events, she helped with killing mordremoth and she even prooved she was stronger than the mordremoths mind corruption.

All was cleared on HoT story and out of nowhere… looks like in S03e01 we are coming again after the caithe dilemma, she is asking (again) for forgiveness, and the PC is reluctant to give her that forgiveness…

I find all that as a mess. We are already over that subject!, she has been proved good, that mistery about if Caithe was bad or good is so 2015, we know she is good and she did what she did (taking and hidding the egg, uhhh lets take her to prison! XD) for the right reasons. You cant trust anyone better than yourself, so she took charge of the issue, as any confident and responsible person would have done.

Enough with the caithe’s blame, enough with the appologize and the misstrust. All this was already cleared on the past.

I start this topic on the forum to ask politely to anet to please, end this nonsense on next episode, make our PC to forgive Caithe, to put some closure to that part of the story (it was closed in HoT and reopened now in epi1, dont know why…) and move on to more interesting things.

I think inconsistency is more of a problem. At one point, everybody is “WE DON’T TRUST YOU YOU SHIFTY VEGETABLE”, and at another, it’s “Okay we’re chill now. Watching you but chill.”

And it gets brought up all the bloody time.

Right. Because if someone you know seemingly thwarts or betrays you, and they apologize, it’s instantly okay again, right? Words are just that, words. Actions prove if someone is reliable, not words. Everybody can speak the right words but there’s no way of knowing if they actually tell the truth until they have a chance to prove it with actions. Caithe did by helping kill the corrupted Faolain and Mordremoth. But still, HoT story never really delved into what Caithe did and how we feel about it afterwards. You also have to keep in mind that Caithe was sneaky, never spoke to us but just took the egg and sneaked off. Considering plenty of Sylvari succumbed to Mordremoth’s call, how would our character know that she was acting on her own or on Mordremoth’s commands? Caithe had her reasons not to trust anyone, but so did we. This part in the current LW chapter is the talk we should have had with Caithe but didn’t in the HoT story. She will keep on proving her loyalty to our cause and in time we will learn to trust her again. That’s how things go in life as well. If someone does something suspicious or outright betrays you, then explains and apologizes for it, trust does not instantly return. If it does, it would mean our character is quite naive, or trusts too easily without solid proof. Considering the position our character has, he/she can’t afford that. Regaining trust is a journey, it’s not instantaneous.