Guild Wars 2

Thank you, anet, this looks absolutely awesome!

But I have a gripe I like to voice. Since it requires the 3 other endless halloween tonics, which are already very costly to make, why is that? I get you would want it to require the 3 endless tonics, but wouldn’t an achievement make more sense, a collection that rewards the wraith tonic?

The endless tonics take a lot of gold to craft (3*10 tattered bat wings at 5g each) so losing them for the wraith seems like a really hars trade-off. Especially when you consider that the update only costs a 4th permanent halloween enchantment, which is 1 corn cob.

So now, if I want the wraith and the 3 endless tonic, I have need 60 tattered bat wings and 1000 of every tonic. is this the intended design?

Yea it didn’t make much sense to me either that it was a recipe and not an achievement, but I guess ANet decided that there were too many mats on the TP that were originally designed to be time limited to around Halloween. So this recipe ensures that hundreds more tonics and various other mats are used in greater numbers.

OriOri.8724:

Yea it didn’t make much sense to me either that it was a recipe and not an achievement, but I guess ANet decided that there were too many mats on the TP that were originally designed to be time limited to around Halloween. So this recipe ensures that hundreds more tonics and various other mats are used in greater numbers.

These tonics are new, though. They werent around last year. Maybe anet thought there was a surplus of tattered bat wings

Isn’t there only like 2000 bat wings on the tp though? They should have made it require also concentrated or regular halloween tonics instead of the bat wings. Give those some value (or at least clear some out).

skullmount.1758:

Isn’t there only like 2000 bat wings on the tp though? They should have made it require also concentrated or regular halloween tonics instead of the bat wings. Give those some value (or at least clear some out).

There may be 2000, but thats very little if everyone needs 40 for the wraith tonic, or 4*X for the Nightfury. That supply will drop fast. Maybe i can gather the gold for it later when im done with adinfinitum