So I have read quite a few posts here, and on other forums about how Melee classes get the shaft. I only speak from experience from the viewpoint of a Guardian, but with the correct setup, I can stand toe to toe for a great deal of time, even against boss mobs that will one-hit kill me.
After a great deal of time rearranging my skills, I have settled on a pretty decent combo that works for me (maybe not for you, but I find it helpful).
1. Equip a Sword
—- This is primarly because of the Blind effect from the skill Flashing Blade. This skill will allow you to negate a single hit every 10 seconds.
2. Take the skill Retreat!
—- This skill will grant you Aegis, and Swiftness. This should be saved for when you are unable to blind your target, and when you do not currently have Aegis active.
3. Take the skill Shield of the Avenger
—- This skill on it’s own is lackluster, but with the trait Eternal Spirit (20 points into Zeal) you can command the shield every 15 seconds to apply the Weakness condition, which reduces the damage the mobs are doing by 50% (non-crit) for 6 seconds. You can apply Weakness this way 2 times every 60 seconds (more if traited)
4. Take the heroic skill Renewed Focus
—- This heroic skill will allow you to be immune to all damage for a few seconds, AND reset the cooldown on your Virtues. Use this skill after you have exhausted your Virtue of Courage for the Aegis boon, to apply it again.
Let me take a moment here to discuss the boon Aegis:
—- The Aegis boon provides you with a magical sheild that will absorb a single hit. Guardians have a passive ability within Virtue of Courage to maintain Aegis until hit, and will recycle every 40 seconds, BUT if you toggle Virtue of Courage directly after the first one is taken away it will grant you an additional Aegis boon. THEN once that Aegis is taken away you can toggle Renewed Focus to reset the cooldown of Virtue of Courage, giving you back your passive Aegis, AND the ability to toggle it again for another Aegis … thats a possible 4 Aegis boons, quite an amazing defensive ability. On top of that the Retreat! skill grants you a 5th Aegis! Toggling Virtue of Courage also grants the Protection boon every time for your group if you go 5 points into Virtues. This reduces all damage by 33% for the duration.
5. Take the trait Blind Exposure.
—- This will allow you to apply the Vulnerability everytime you blind your target. Taking this trait will also get you the prior minor trait Justice is Blind, which will add the Blind effect to ALL nearby mobs everytime you activate Virtue of Justice. Combined with the Elite skill Renewed Focus you can use this ability twice every 30 seconds.
6. Take the heal skill Shelter.
—- This skill heals for quite a bit less than the Signet heal, but it has the added effect of Blocking all incoming attacks until the heal goes off. This lasts for 2 seconds, so if you time this right between your Aegis cooldowns it can act as a great defensive filler.
So lets RECAP:
As a Sword guardian you can:
-Apply blind every 10 seconds with Flashing Blade
-Apply blind every ~15 seconds with the trait Blind Exposure
-Apply Weakness to mobs in an AoE twice per minute for 6 seconds each (thats 20% upkeep[more if traited])
-Grant yourself the boon Aegis about 6 times 60 seconds
-Grant yourself the boon Protection twice every 90 seconds
-Take the heal skill Shelter for 2 seconds of Blocking every 30 seconds.
I would also highly recommend you focus on Conditional Damage and take traits that boost the Burning condition. It may even be a good idea to take the skill Sword of Justice. You are already going to have the trait that allows you to Command your spirit weapons without destroying them, if you take the trait A Fire Inside your Commanded sword will cause the Burning condition to all enemies in an AoE around it. The damage from this build has been quite good, and I have rarely died. Just keep in mind you still have to do a lot of moving around and when you run out of defensive abilities, back up for a few seconds, then get back in there when things start to recycle.
Please keep in mind that while this build may work very well for me, it may not for you … but it sure is fun to set things on fire and be nearly invulnerable in melee range while my defences are up!