Question: Guild Auctions

Question: Guild Auctions

in Players Helping Players

Posted by: Nefarious.1973

Nefarious.1973

My question is. If I wanted to sell my guild for gold, am I able to do so? Or is it a violation of any rules? I lurked around and could not find any information on this.

Question: Guild Auctions

in Players Helping Players

Posted by: Omne.4603

Omne.4603

Pretty sure thats legit.

I Cant Stop/ Ocularis
NSP | Os Guild Master
www.osguild.org | www.youtube.com/osthink

Question: Guild Auctions

in Players Helping Players

Posted by: eXs.6210

eXs.6210

Violation or not, it’s still a pretty sad day in the history of humanity when we want to sell something for profit whose sole point was to bring people together, become friends, socialize and play some games together… This isn’t a corporation… your guildmates are your friends… and if all that they’re worth to you is the highest gold bid on an addiction, then you’re a terrible leader that doesn’t deserve a guild our any benefits that come from being in one…

Question: Guild Auctions

in Players Helping Players

Posted by: Uther Deathhand.1570

Uther Deathhand.1570

Wow eXs that is a little harsh don’t you think? Did you ever think that maybe the guild is just a few of his friends and they don’t want the name any more so they are going to make a new one? And even if it is a big guild if its “his” then i think it will be fine. And if this is the worst thing that happens today then i would say it is a pretty kitten good day for human history.

Work for a cause, not for applause.
Live life to express, not to impress.
Don’t strive to make your presence noticed, just make your absence felt. ~ unknown

Question: Guild Auctions

in Players Helping Players

Posted by: Daemon Hawk.9406

Daemon Hawk.9406

eXs, it might be a guild that is basically a glorified bank tab, having nothing to do with other people. That said, I wouldn’t hang around a guild that had been sold.

Garik Ravenclaw
Support Beastmaster Ranger
http://garik.fastmail.fm

Question: Guild Auctions

in Players Helping Players

Posted by: Nefarious.1973

Nefarious.1973

Appreciate the responses. Been busy with work, school, kids, etc to respond sooner.

eXs. Is that really your first assumption and only “hypothesis” as to why I’m selling MY guild that I created? Well, you know what they say, ignorance is bliss.

Question: Guild Auctions

in Players Helping Players

Posted by: mercury ranique.2170

mercury ranique.2170

Yes there is no problem with selling a guild (beside moral reasons like eXs pointed out, but that depends on the situation). The only thing I would like to point out is that a guild can’t be sold on the TP, and where in gw1 a lot of scammers existed, due to the TP a lot of them are out of business. The few hardocre ones (and the worse imo) however remains. and the selling of a guild comes down to trust…. so make sure they dont misuse you.

Arise, ye farmers of all nations
Arise, opressed of Tyria!

Question: Guild Auctions

in Players Helping Players

Posted by: draakdorei.9436

draakdorei.9436

Violation or not, it’s still a pretty sad day in the history of humanity when we want to sell something for profit whose sole point was to bring people together, become friends, socialize and play some games together… This isn’t a corporation… your guildmates are your friends… and if all that they’re worth to you is the highest gold bid on an addiction, then you’re a terrible leader that doesn’t deserve a guild our any benefits that come from being in one…

While I can see your point, that is quite a bit harsh.

@OP, you might want to put a bit more description into your question to avoid future responses like above.

Something like: personal bank guild with X benefits unlocked

Would be more helpful in getting proper responses.

I don’t think there is anything immoral about selling personal guilds nor guilds that are being changed (i.e. merging with another one and disbanding the former).

Draakdorei – L80 Sylvari Engineer Support/Healer
Drake Rovan – L80 Human Ranger AoE Ranger/Spirit Buffer

Question: Guild Auctions

in Players Helping Players

Posted by: Nefarious.1973

Nefarious.1973

Violation or not, it’s still a pretty sad day in the history of humanity when we want to sell something for profit whose sole point was to bring people together, become friends, socialize and play some games together… This isn’t a corporation… your guildmates are your friends… and if all that they’re worth to you is the highest gold bid on an addiction, then you’re a terrible leader that doesn’t deserve a guild our any benefits that come from being in one…

While I can see your point, that is quite a bit harsh.

@OP, you might want to put a bit more description into your question to avoid future responses like above.

Something like: personal bank guild with X benefits unlocked

Would be more helpful in getting proper responses.

I don’t think there is anything immoral about selling personal guilds nor guilds that are being changed (i.e. merging with another one and disbanding the former).

I appreciate the suggestion, however. I don’t believe in anyway my question warranted such a bitter response. The rant is based on nothing, but imagination and honestly his ignorance made me smile today ;]

Thanks again to everyone for all the helpful suggestions!!!