Guild Wars 2

I remember reading something about how you could get the achievement by equipping the twilight/sunrise(?) then use them to make eternity and be able to sell it, or at least something to this effect.

Is this possible? I don’t recall the exact details that were mentioned at the time. If someone could enlighten me that would be appreciated.

Additionally is there a ‘cheap’ or ‘efficient’ way to get the achievement?

Thanks in advance.

You need two of the exact same legendary, so the cheapest method of getting this would be going for either an underwater legendary or the bard

OP: you might be thinking of the following advice:

• Craft Sunrise, Craft Twilight. Do not bind them.
• Sell them.
• With your money, buy Eternity and bind it.

This unlocks 5 skins for your wardrobe: Dawn, Dusk, Sunrise, Twilight, and Eternity at the lowest possible cost.

Illconceived Was Na.9781:

OP: you might be thinking of the following advice:

• Craft Sunrise, Craft Twilight. Do not bind them.
• Sell them.
• With your money, buy Eternity and bind it.

This unlocks 5 skins for your wardrobe: Dawn, Dusk, Sunrise, Twilight, and Eternity at the lowest possible cost.

But it does not give you the achievement and title Twice-told Legend.

To do that you have to bind two identical legendaries. As in two Sunrises, two Twilights, two Moot’s etc.

(The achievement was put in to compensate those who crafted two matching legendaries before the wardrobe update – back then it was the only way to dual wield them, now it’s wasted effort.)

Danikat.8537:

Illconceived Was Na.9781:

OP: you might be thinking of the following advice:

• Craft Sunrise, Craft Twilight. Do not bind them.
• Sell them.
• With your money, buy Eternity and bind it.

This unlocks 5 skins for your wardrobe: Dawn, Dusk, Sunrise, Twilight, and Eternity at the lowest possible cost.

But it does not give you the achievement and title Twice-told Legend.

To do that you have to bind two identical legendaries. As in two Sunrises, two Twilights, two Moot’s etc.

(The achievement was put in to compensate those who crafted two matching legendaries before the wardrobe update – back then it was the only way to dual wield them, now it’s wasted effort.)

Or a bound twilight/sunrise and a bound eternity.

Ok I think some people might be confusing the two different achievements you get for binding legendary weapons.

Legendary Collector is for binding unique legendaries. The first tier is 1, tier 2 is 2 and the max tier is 5. This requires you to have different legendaries, so Sunrise, Twilight and Eternity would get you to tier 3.

Twice-told Legend is for binding two duplicate legendaries. Meaning two of the exact same ones. As the description says: “Present a matching pair of bound legendary weapons to Historian Dozza in Divinity’s Reach.”

Since Twilight, Sunrise and Eternity are not all identical they don’t count.

(Also you have to actually have both legendaries with you when you speak to the NPC to get the achievement.)

Danikat.8537:

Ok I think some people might be confusing the two different achievements you get for binding legendary weapons.

Legendary Collector is for binding unique legendaries. The first tier is 1, tier 2 is 2 and the max tier is 5. This requires you to have different legendaries, so Sunrise, Twilight and Eternity would get you to tier 3.

Twice-told Legend is for binding two duplicate legendaries. Meaning two of the exact same ones. As the description says: “Present a matching pair of bound legendary weapons to Historian Dozza in Divinity’s Reach.”

Since Twilight, Sunrise and Eternity are not all identical they don’t count.

(Also you have to actually have both legendaries with you when you speak to the NPC to get the achievement.)

They have awarded credit for that achievement if someone has eternity bound and either sunrise or twilight bound as well. This is because eternity is a special case in that it uses both of those weapons to create it.

Ayrilana.1396:

Danikat.8537:

Ok I think some people might be confusing the two different achievements you get for binding legendary weapons.

Legendary Collector is for binding unique legendaries. The first tier is 1, tier 2 is 2 and the max tier is 5. This requires you to have different legendaries, so Sunrise, Twilight and Eternity would get you to tier 3.

Twice-told Legend is for binding two duplicate legendaries. Meaning two of the exact same ones. As the description says: “Present a matching pair of bound legendary weapons to Historian Dozza in Divinity’s Reach.”

Since Twilight, Sunrise and Eternity are not all identical they don’t count.

(Also you have to actually have both legendaries with you when you speak to the NPC to get the achievement.)

They have awarded credit for that achievement if someone has eternity bound and either sunrise or twilight bound as well. This is because eternity is a special case in that it uses both of those weapons to create it.

Do you have a source for that?

I tried searching online (both this site specifically and the internet generally) and didn’t see any mention of Anet awarding the achievement to people who made Eternity, but a lot of discussions where someone theorised that would work and were told it wouldn’t.

Such as this one on this forum:
https://forum-en.gw2archive.eu/forum/game/gw2/Twice-Told-Legend-really/first#post4250274

Danikat.8537:

Ayrilana.1396:

Danikat.8537:

Ok I think some people might be confusing the two different achievements you get for binding legendary weapons.

Legendary Collector is for binding unique legendaries. The first tier is 1, tier 2 is 2 and the max tier is 5. This requires you to have different legendaries, so Sunrise, Twilight and Eternity would get you to tier 3.

Twice-told Legend is for binding two duplicate legendaries. Meaning two of the exact same ones. As the description says: “Present a matching pair of bound legendary weapons to Historian Dozza in Divinity’s Reach.”

Since Twilight, Sunrise and Eternity are not all identical they don’t count.

(Also you have to actually have both legendaries with you when you speak to the NPC to get the achievement.)

They have awarded credit for that achievement if someone has eternity bound and either sunrise or twilight bound as well. This is because eternity is a special case in that it uses both of those weapons to create it.

Do you have a source for that?

I tried searching online (both this site specifically and the internet generally) and didn’t see any mention of Anet awarding the achievement to people who made Eternity, but a lot of discussions where someone theorised that would work and were told it wouldn’t.

Such as this one on this forum:
https://forum-en.gw2archive.eu/forum/game/gw2/Twice-Told-Legend-really/first#post4250274

Not sure if there’s one on the forums but people have submitted support tickets and gotten it that way.

All i can say i made Eternity and don’t have that title. But i’m not sure if i had
bound Twilight. But it would make no sense in my eyes to give the title for that
because in my eyes its the intended way to get eternity, and the whole get skins
of sunrise and twilight, and sell eternity .. its more a kind of bug / oversight for me.

Beldin.5498:

All i can say i made Eternity and don’t have that title. But i’m not sure if i had bound Twilight.

Think they are saying if you had an Eternity + an additional bound Twilight/Sunrise. Not the ones used to craft it.