Guild Wars 2

I’ve been going off this guide to make most of my sPvP gear http://www.guildwars2guru.com/topic/55030-pvp-mystic-forge-recipes/

For my weapons, I wanted to make the corrupted equivalent of sword and dagger (Icy Dragon would be awesome, but from what I can tell, that hasn’t been discovered yet). Confusion lies in the fact that the guide lists frozen and etched under deer, and there are two “Etched Blade”s in the pvp locker, one the regular svanir looking and one the corrupted(frozen) looking.

I tried a couple times of combining sword + deer + dust + sliver and just got the non-frozen Etched blade. Is it just RNG to get the frozen versions, or is there a better guide out there for this?

I wish there was a better guide out there. Unfortunately that is what I use as well.