Guild Wars 2

Would it be possible to get leaderboards for guilds in spvp? Similar to how it worked in gw1. If you have at least 3 players on the team that are from the same guild it would count towards their ranking, and this would be published on the official leaderboards.

It is a Guarantee it will happen n soon , you heard it here first , nah seriously its what makes a competitive spirit n thrives pvp is a guild ladder/leaderboard

Quick Mouse.7635:

Would it be possible to get leaderboards for guilds in spvp? Similar to how it worked in gw1. If you have at least 3 players on the team that are from the same guild it would count towards their ranking, and this would be published on the official leaderboards.

wouldn’t really be taken too seriously, since a player can just join multiple guilds and stuff, it still mostly boils down to which players are the best, rather than which guild.

It worked in GW1 because guild memberships were more… enclosed, for lack of a better word, an account was bound to 1 single guild and only that single guild until you left.

lmaonade.9207:

Quick Mouse.7635:

Would it be possible to get leaderboards for guilds in spvp? Similar to how it worked in gw1. If you have at least 3 players on the team that are from the same guild it would count towards their ranking, and this would be published on the official leaderboards.

wouldn’t really be taken too seriously, since a player can just join multiple guilds and stuff, it still mostly boils down to which players are the best, rather than which guild.

It worked in GW1 because guild memberships were more… enclosed, for lack of a better word, an account was bound to 1 single guild and only that single guild until you left.

I disagree with the notion that it wouldn’t be taken seriously. Top tier guilds will still only recruit top tier players. Being a top tier player, you wouldn’t be stuck in one guild either.
In gw1 there were alliances where guilds basically shared players. Several top tier guilds would form an alliance, similar to the gw2 multi-guild function in a backwards sort of way.

Quick Mouse.7635:

lmaonade.9207:

Quick Mouse.7635:

Would it be possible to get leaderboards for guilds in spvp? Similar to how it worked in gw1. If you have at least 3 players on the team that are from the same guild it would count towards their ranking, and this would be published on the official leaderboards.

wouldn’t really be taken too seriously, since a player can just join multiple guilds and stuff, it still mostly boils down to which players are the best, rather than which guild.

It worked in GW1 because guild memberships were more… enclosed, for lack of a better word, an account was bound to 1 single guild and only that single guild until you left.

I disagree with the notion that it wouldn’t be taken seriously. Top tier guilds will still only recruit top tier players. Being a top tier player, you wouldn’t be stuck in one guild either.
In gw1 there were alliances where guilds basically shared players. Several top tier guilds would form an alliance, similar to the gw2 multi-guild function in a backwards sort of way.

Or maybe top tier players will be subject to things like “sponsership” and such to play for certain guilds, so you basically have 20+ guilds on the leaderboard but all of those games were won by the same exact people. That’s not exactly different from a players leaderboard, except to the guilds themselves.

How would it be taken seriously if all the top tier guilds shared players? I don’t even see how it could be taken seriously by themselves, since they aren’t competing with each other or other people (since they dominate the ladder)

What about us players that play on multiple teams?

Put a limit such that a guild cant gain in rankings in a particular match if they have a team member playing who has rep another guild in a pvp match for the past X weeks? Some kind of limit would work, since it’s not about teams here and you are not restricted to playing with the same 5 person all the time.

Well, exchanging ppl as “guests” is not working on the topend. The communication in this game is so important that it’s hard to integrate a top player form another team in your own one. This rule applies also for strats, as many teams have different special strats they only can coordinate if 5 players have knowledge about it.

So I’m not sure if this “guesting in multiple guilds” is such a big issue.