Guild Wars 2

Just to clear up:

Stone Heart [ELE] – You cannot be critically hit when attuned to earth.

Hidden Killer [THIEF] – Gain bonus critical-hit chance while in stealth. Critical Chance increase: 100%

Sigil of Intelligence - Your next attack after swapping to this weapon while in combat has a 100% critical chance.

Imagine a situation when thief, traited with Hidden Killer / active Sigil of Intelligence backstabs elementalist, that is using Stone Heart. What happens then?

This issue is important, because if crit chance that is over 100% negates Stone Heart, upcoming bunker ele will be exposed to great danger.

What do you think of it?

Seems pretty straight forward to me. The thief attacks with an attack that would be a critical hit, except that Stone Hearth prevents the hit from being a critical when it hits the ele.

I.e. Stone Heart negating all criticals, including ‘guaranteed’ crits seems to make the most sense.

100% * 0 = 0%
200% * 0 = 0%

Unless Stone Heart subtracts percentage (which would allow >100% crit chance to still sometimes crit), this should work fine.

If

Hidden Killer [THIEF] – Your next attack attack is a critical hit while you’re in stealth.

Then

It would be something to make your brain crack.

Menzies The Heretic.3415:

If

Hidden Killer [THIEF] – Your next attack attack is a critical hit while you’re in stealth.

Then

It would be something to make your brain crack.

This was the description long ago. Now they say you have +100% crit chance

what would be an even greater paradox (well not really a paradox) would be if retaliation returned retaliation damage!
2 guardians… both with retaliation, one hits the other, both instantly take infinite damage, server crashes from the infinite flood of numbers in a single instance. :P