Guild Wars 2

Shouldn’t we simply face people of the same division (and same tier if possible)? Top teams facing each other in amber, people tanking MMR for easy climb, etc, these could all be solved by this.

Because nobody thought about it.
It should be implemented exacly as you said…

You play in Emerald or higher and Amber guys don’t even give kitten if they lose.

I thought it would be like this.

I guess the main problem is that the very first games would be fully random matching, and thus inherently unfair. But after about a week, this would have somewhat settled.

also they can make it that if you are up againts a team with an average division ratio which is 2 division above your teams average division ration than you dont lose a point if you lose the match.