Guild Wars 2

It’s always be a problem that some guild with low upgrade claim almost any objetive. Because in a moment of need you need that upgrade… In this case Im writing about +5 aura…. before HoT any guild could had the +5 buff but now is an upgrade really hard to get… it’s more sustancial upgrade and think is just in the right place but it will be nice if after don’t know 2 min of claim it a guild with a better level of aura can overwrite the one before and claim the objetive.
All guild need to show Up in a way claiming is one of them if the work hard to take a big objetive way don’t get some credit without diminish your servers in any way.

This has been discussed before, while it would appear at first glance that giving overwrite claim ability would be of advantage to a server;

Guilds who were present at the time of capture and are trying to Capture, claim and upgrade a structure for a guild mission have the right to do so.

IMHO, If the over write ability was to be used, strict penalties would have to apply for those who overwrite and destroy an active guild mission.

Personally I think overwrites should not be possible, and while “unclaiming” might have some potential it could also easily be abused.

I don’t know if it’s intentional or not, but any guild can set up the improvements/tactics now; which at least partly resolves the problem.

But I agree, some hierarchical ability to swap out lower auras for higher ones would be nice. The trick would be finding a way to do it without arbitrarily swapping out for the same aura.

elkirin.8534:

Guilds who were present at the time of capture and are trying to Capture, claim and upgrade a structure for a guild mission have the right to do so.

IMHO, If the over write ability was to be used, strict penalties would have to apply for those who overwrite and destroy an active guild mission.

You do not need claim an objetive for guild mision, with cap it and defender it it’s ok. And you do not lose any upgrade place it on the objetive when you change the claiming (that is happening now)

Hesacon.8735:

The trick would be finding a way to do it without arbitrarily swapping out for the same aura.

Can use the level aura… guild A go an claim a tower with a 4 level aura, then came guild B and try to claim it… if guild B has 5 level aura o more can claim it if not no.

My goodness, you guys are so greedy for your +5 you are willing to upset your own server mates and label them trolls just for the sake of slightly more efficient feeding of supply to your swollen blob.

A week or so ago my guild took back Quentin Lake and claimed it. We spent all day defending it, defending Danelon, building the siege, walking the yaks, scouting, killing the roamers. We were there for hours. NA prime rolls around and some blobber demands we give up our claim so they can get +5.

Excuse me? We took and looked after this tower. We have every aura except +5. You don’t get to log in hours later and announce that your 200 man pvx guild deserves to over write our claim.

We have 4 people upgrading our guild. Every one of us has to be dragged kicking and screaming away from wvw because it’s what we enjoy and what we are very very good at. Why should we be punished for both being small and being wvw dedicated by being treated like second class citizens?

Instead of demanding you can over ride other guilds claims just to get +5 aura why dont you instead consider fostering a good community on your server and donating the mats small guilds are struggling to obtain?

Thank you for clearing up the misconception I had where the mission says claim and upgrade it must only mean Capture and wait.

If that is the case then;

I like the suggestion of asking servers to provide the small guilds with the materials to upgrade all auras.

Celsith.2753:

My goodness, you guys are so greedy for your +5 you are willing to upset your own server mates and label them trolls just for the sake of slightly more efficient feeding of supply to your swollen blob.

A week or so ago my guild took back Quentin Lake and claimed it. We spent all day defending it, defending Danelon, building the siege, walking the yaks, scouting, killing the roamers. We were there for hours. NA prime rolls around and some blobber demands we give up our claim so they can get +5.

Excuse me? We took and looked after this tower. We have every aura except +5. You don’t get to log in hours later and announce that your 200 man pvx guild deserves to over write our claim.

We have 4 people upgrading our guild. Every one of us has to be dragged kicking and screaming away from wvw because it’s what we enjoy and what we are very very good at. Why should we be punished for both being small and being wvw dedicated by being treated like second class citizens?

Instead of demanding you can over ride other guilds claims just to get +5 aura why dont you instead consider fostering a good community on your server and donating the mats small guilds are struggling to obtain?

That actualy my point.. any guild have the right for claim and objetive… and in some case situations like you describe happen, and they are bad experiencie for new guilds and new player…. other situations, some guild are “false” (or not) accused to be trolls or spy because they claim and objetive, some time i was runing with a big pug zerg and a new guild with the mayority of the people on the zerg was claiming every objetive we toke, and they do not have even aura 3 on their claiming… making the zerg less effective on carry supplies and the commander more grumpy (sorry my English) because they ask to the members of that guild do not claim, and they keep claiming…

I’m trying to avoid that situation giving a middle ground… The new guild of WvW need to be know… and the most effective way is claiming… why do not allow to this new guild to be know and in case of need can be change the claiming for a more upgrade it guild?

Instead of overriding I would suggest something similar to how the guild buffs can be applied by other guilds that do not have claim over a structure. Therefore a guild can claim a structure but if they dont have all the buffs, it can be supplmented by another guild the same way buffs are.

In the case of a tower, I don’t really care who claims it, the +5 isn’t a vital thing for towers. But Keeps for sure, if there’s an option for +5 supply it needs to be on there.

I like the idea of overvriting, I have problem with some kind of trolls/very inexprinced players that claim towers and camps with 2 first auras(and they have 2 guilds to do it, that’s why I think they’re trolls), they completly deny the +5 and buffs, It’s nice that we can still put some tactics tho

Claim the objective when you capture it. Your guild has 10 seconds to claim it before anyone else has the chance. Once claimed the objective stays that way until you allow the enemies capture it or until you intentionally give up your claim.

one guild can have one objective on map claimed at once and my guild still don’t have full buffs, that’s why I’m not claiming stuff unless I want to siege it up and defend( after leaving it I’m caliming camp to let others get +5 on it)