Is it a Bad idea? or Good?
What does need changing for the commander tag is the option to make it private and have it display different colours to differentiate. Buffs for commanders or for people around the commander are a bad idea.
The way of procuring the item should change indeed.
Months ago I suggested it be done with badges. The wannabe commander could buy an npc and people could donate badges to that npc so the wannabe commander can buy his icon with the badges. A reasonable price for the icon should be somewhere around 10k badges. This would still not guarantee that a commander is good but it does show that he has some support from WvW players and if he has 10k badges on his own (not that unlikely) it shows that he actually plays WvW.
P.S. don’t be afraid of messing with commanders
7.2k+ hours played on Minesweeper
I must disagree with adding extra bonuses for wearing the tag as this would encourage min maxers to buy them and an increase in them as a whole, which gets cluttered.
Although I do believe that commanders should have more options within thier tag, such as visible to guild only, squad only, or the entire friendly map. They should also have many more options available to the squad function, such as a team setup menu, to put players in teams, see thier names and professions etc. There are many options to explore in a squad menu and I hope they recognize the potential of it.
Champion Paragon – #Magswag
I guess it is really a bad idea. I had a bad feeling of it as well. Well I guess I’m gonna have to go to plan B. Lol