Random Match Ups
This is a terrible idea, yes.
For Europe, only the bottom 2 tiers are a complete mess. ArenaNet should simply address how slow turnover happens at the lower tiers and everything is fine. I feel terrible for servers like Whiteside Ridge.
http://www.youtube.com/user/IntigoGW2
Well the American servers are a mess lol.
Over a one week period? Would be 100x more awful than the current format. You’d luck out to find a balanced matchup since the quality/numbers between servers of different tiers is very significant. What you’re proposing is the possibility of three servers from different tiers playing against one another, sometihng like tier 2 server A vs tier 4 server B vs tier 7 server C.
Outcome is entirely predictable and matchups would be decided in minutes to hours (at most a day). Blowouts galore. And no that doesnt mean one server winning by 50-60k like current formats but rather one server winning by 300k.
Would you seriously prefer that?