1) (or place a 1 week cooldown on WvW activities as a punishment for trying to change the direction of a match)
2) (wouldn’t be fair for everyone that would like to play in WvW and to be honest it only takes 5 people to take doors down on keeps/towers/castles…so in theory if there were number balancing, and only 5 people were in WvW, that means only 5 would be allowed from the other two servers each….see the problem with that)
3) (portals and thieves make it interesting, though the amount of “stealth” is kinda crazy. I’m sure Anet was not trying to make a WoW thief which would be why stealth is limited, but there’s so many stealth options that a thief could if planned right stay invis a good portion of the time. Mesmer’s seem really OP in WvW though in general, portals aside).
4) (Or just make the orbs less desirable to have or give a different buff)
5) (I have no better idea here as that would be beneficial to the players that come forward to help build up these keeps/towers…because we that defend and build up these places know that you can literally spend upwards of 6g on a keep and around 3g on a tower just for the upgrades).
6) (Would create lag. There’s plenty of “free” server programs out there that people have access to.)
7) (This is a double-edged sword. Why not instead give us the upgrade ability to strengthen doors to the same level that the T3 walls can go to. That would make the door just as hard to get through as the walls and would make it to where it would take more effort than just a few people to take a door down).
8) (Agree).
9) (Some of this is if you don’t control the nodes in your primary map. The rest of this I’ve read is because you’re not meant to have siege permanently…a currency sink if you will).
10) (This would be nice, but, they’d have to make sure that you couldn’t just turn it on or off. I would recommend that if this were enabled, that a 48 hour cooldown was placed on the switchability of it…this way your new friend can’t take advantage of the system and go foe from inside your newly acquired keep or tower. Also, when join ventures are taken both sides involved should get the points for those pieces of property as well as on the map it should show half one color, half the other on the property taken.)
11) (This should be an option, but just to point out, Toughness is the universal protection against NPCs and Players. If anything maybe the PvP gear needs to go like many other games have where the PvP gear has a specific stat that only gives protection against players.)
12) (In the current state, to be honest, a wooden door could be “axed, burned, etc” and those are real life mechanics. Give gates the ability to be upgraded to a third tier where only siege can be used to tear it down, that would add a nice option to defense vs. attacking. Also, the hitpoints on cannons/oil/mortars should be doubled at least. As it stands right now, you can destroy a tower/keep’s ability to defend with very little resistance. Make attackers work harder to take something so when they do they really can take that gratification to the bank).
13) (Agree. Or larger raids. It’s not like we need to see their health bars as you can scroll over a person and get that. It would just be nice to get more like-minded individuals on your attack team than be forced to try to get 5 separate groups to figure out what you’re doing).
14) (How about instead they added the ability to transfer supplies from camps you own to keeps/towers/castle. In other words, if you can successfully defend a camp line between your property and that camp, you should be able to run supplies back to your defense point and deposit them into the main supply which would make up for that idiot that wipes your supply out at a keep/tower with upgrades that aren’t necessary during a defense campaign).
15) (Workers should be repairing anything that has been hit but not destroyed when there is supply to do it. I think this was bad implementation on Anet’s part. Like when cannon’s re-appear or the oil bin after being destroyed, those workers should be doing their NPC job and getting those defenses back up. However in terms of when something has been destroyed, a player should have to initiate the first repair sequence while the siege is still going on, much like your ability to repair a gate while it is being sieged).
Cmdr. Xandria Wolfkin
[RED] Devona’s Rest
