Best weapons for random dungeon PUGs?
Every team could be different, I don’t think there is any one right answer here. I would say pick your favorite weapons that you like to play with and have them on hand so you can pick up any slack a pug might have. Guardians can be pretty flexible so I generally keep a greatsword, a staff, a sword, a shield, a focus, and a hammer on me at all times. In my groups I usually roll with at least a Ranger and a Thief, so I tend towards a sword and shield / staff combo to support, control, and spread might while they dish out tons of damage, but depending on any pickups / guildies that come along I can tweak more in some areas with the equipment.
Staff and shield are the best when you are stacking boon duration, otherwise stick to higher damage AOE options like hammer/GS + scepter for when you have to sit back. You still get good support with your utilities even without speccing much.
I guess there’s merit in bringing every weapon, but 1h sword/mace are weak unless your build specifically focuses on them (right hand strength/symbols).
Thanks for the replies!