Guild Wars 2

really!?

My guard is a female norn – I will use this as an excuse for my poor guardian play lol

This was brought up almost 2 years ago if I recall. The community seemed divided at the time, some said it was not true and the skill dealt the same damage no matter your character, others claimed male Human/Sylvari were doing more damage.

Either way, if there is an issue, it has been around since the launch of the game, so don’t expect ANET to fix it.

This is still not fixed?!

At this point I’m thinking about starting a fundraiser or something. If they aren’t willing to fix all these bugs we just pay someone to do it.

Can someone from Anet say how much this would cost approximately?

yes I also made a thread after changing my guardian human male to female, my whirlwind wrath suffered a huge loss. however it doesn’t seems to apply to norn female since i made a new one after seeing that my WW wasn’t hitting every hit. I see a lot more 40ks + when doing dungeon now which I never did with my human female.

Can you please post this in the general forum so it can be seen

Azure.8670:

Can you please post this in the general forum so it can be seen

It doesn’t matter… There are Numerous bugs that’s been around since launch. For some reason Anet isn’t worried about it.

This may sound silly…but if we develop a petition to fix these bugs then it may actually go through. Would need an extensive list of ingame bugs, 800 worth of signed names, stick it in Anet’s face then maybe they’ll take care of it.

Saiyan.1704:

Azure.8670:

Can you please post this in the general forum so it can be seen

It doesn’t matter… There are Numerous bugs that’s been around since launch. For some reason Anet isn’t worried about it.

This may sound silly…but if we develop a petition to fix these bugs then it may actually go through. Would need an extensive list of ingame bugs, 800 worth of signed names, stick it in Anet’s face then maybe they’ll take care of it.

This has hardly any effect on casual PvE so why would they fix it?

EFWinters.5421:

Saiyan.1704:

Azure.8670:

Can you please post this in the general forum so it can be seen

It doesn’t matter… There are Numerous bugs that’s been around since launch. For some reason Anet isn’t worried about it.

This may sound silly…but if we develop a petition to fix these bugs then it may actually go through. Would need an extensive list of ingame bugs, 800 worth of signed names, stick it in Anet’s face then maybe they’ll take care of it.

This has hardly any effect on casual PvE so why would they fix it?

Actually the only bug I want fixed is “teleport”. It currently has the shadow step mechmic. That’s really all I want fixed

Sorry for the bump but I did some more tests.

Used the exact same build each time, and the target was a heavy golem. Used a male asura, male human, female human, and male charr. Each test was carried out exactly in the middle of the golem’s model(to the best of my ability to judge the “middle”)

Originally I planned to do 20 tests for each but I stopped at the ten mark simply because the results were obvious.

Male Human – 14 hits, 100% of the time

Female Human – 12 hits, 100% of the time

Male Charr – 12 hits, 100% of the time

Male Asura – 12 hits, 100% of the time

tl;dr time to make a human male guardian

Edit: I would like to test if using Ascalonian Tonic on a female human guardian changes anything. Sadly I can’t use tonics in HoTM, meaning I can’t really test this unless someone from BG/JQ is willing to help out. If you’re interested PM me in game.

Okay so I did more testing, this time with an actual player as a target.

Results for human male guardian were as expected, 14 hits

But then I tried charr guardian… My combat log showed 12 hits
http://i.imgur.com/JsSbCdE.jpg

but my assistant’s(the target) combat log showed 14
http://i.imgur.com/GynX7Wj.jpg

We repeated the tests multiple times and it was the same result.

tl;dr probably combat log issue rather than an issue with whirling wrath, no need to reroll as human male guardian!!

Nothing quite as awful as the human female shouts.