Suggestion regarding a trait rearrangement

Suggestion regarding a trait rearrangement

in Guardian

Posted by: Pitman.9210

Pitman.9210

Look at the Honor trait line.

Swap the minor trait Selfless Daring (The end of your dodge roll heals nearby allies.)
with Elusive Power (Deal more damage while your endurance is not full.)

Remove the icd from the major trait Empowering Might (You and nearby allies gain might when you land a critical hit) and reduce the might duration to 4 seconds (from 5).
Change its positon with Force of Will (You have increased vitality based on your level.) and maybe nerf Force of Will if need to.

I think this could make some very interesting builds possible. Drop meditations for shouts in an dps build. You get more codi removal and support but loose dmg and/or toughness depending on how you build it.

Thoughts?

Suggestion regarding a trait rearrangement

in Guardian

Posted by: xFireize.6318

xFireize.6318

Removing Empowering Might’s CD has been requested a lot of times, but that’s not gonna happen.

Let’s compare the healing effect to this food. Empowering Might is stronger (100% chance to proc on crit and 25 more HP heal). In the early days of GW2, that food did not have 1s internal cooldown, and everyone in WvW was using it because it was so good. Anet realized it was OP so they added the internal cool down.

Bloo Foefire [RAM]
Yak’s Bend
Why bother being a Guardian if you don’t guard anyone?

Suggestion regarding a trait rearrangement

in Guardian

Posted by: Pitman.9210

Pitman.9210

I can see that. If we compare it with the Warrior then we see that he needs greatsword and 10 points for the same effect.
I just feel like that there is a lot of potential for build diversity if someone could get this to work.
Maybe reducing the might duration even further?

Suggestion regarding a trait rearrangement

in Guardian

Posted by: xFireize.6318

xFireize.6318

Don’t warriors need 20 for that GS trait?

Like I said, the problem is not on the might duration — even if it has no internal cooldown, I would still use it when it has only 1s AoE might. It’s already one of the best AH booster traits even with 1s cooldown. When I was running AH build, I avoided that trait because it is so strong (unless I’m fighting 40+ man zerg), and picked two-handed mastery instead.

Could you explain the potential build diversity that would come up?

Bloo Foefire [RAM]
Yak’s Bend
Why bother being a Guardian if you don’t guard anyone?

Suggestion regarding a trait rearrangement

in Guardian

Posted by: CptAurellian.9537

CptAurellian.9537

EM’s ICD is fine, otherwise it would become ridiculous in conjunction with GS #2. However, the range should be increased to 600 and the duration to something like 10-15 seconds. Right now, it’s a bad joke compared to what a warrior can do with the phalanx strength trait.

Warning! This post may contain traces of irony, sarcasm and peanuts.

There is no loyalty without betrayal. -Ann Smiley

Suggestion regarding a trait rearrangement

in Guardian

Posted by: Pitman.9210

Pitman.9210

Don’t warriors need 20 for that GS trait?

Like I said, the problem is not on the might duration — even if it has no internal cooldown, I would still use it when it has only 1s AoE might. It’s already one of the best AH booster traits even with 1s cooldown. When I was running AH build, I avoided that trait because it is so strong (unless I’m fighting 40+ man zerg), and picked two-handed mastery instead.

Could you explain the potential build diversity that would come up?

I mean 10 points in the new trait system. 4 points to get the might on crit trait with greatsword and 6 for the sharing.

You are right, this would be nuts…

Mostly pvp builds. Let’s see:

2/1/2/6/1 – Berserker dmg build with reduced cd for Judge’ Intervention, 2 shouts, the “conditions into boons when hit by shout” trait. More team support but less dmg. The Force of Will trait helps us with conditions. Less toughness.

2/2/2/4/4 – Maybe making the healing signet viable again. Reduced signet cd and stability through Virtues and shouts. Force of Will as master trait again.

2/1/6/4/1 – Meditation build with berserker amulet. A more hp oriented version of this build.

EM’s ICD is fine, otherwise it would become ridiculous in conjunction with GS #2. However, the range should be increased to 600 and the duration to something like 10-15 seconds. Right now, it’s a bad joke compared to what a warrior can do with the phalanx strength trait.

This would help against long boss encounters in pve. But it sadly doesn’t really help us in pvp with our poor mobility. It would be great if we can make this work as well. And don’t mention scepter, I feel like a dog eating a lemon everytime I hear about that thing…

Suggestion regarding a trait rearrangement

in Guardian

Posted by: CptAurellian.9537

CptAurellian.9537

Then work directly on the core problem, mobility. This game is the perfect example that band-aid solutions ignoring core problems just create new problems instead of fixing anything.

But in the end, no matter what you suggest, nothing will happen anyway. The devs are to dumb and/or lazy to address the myriad issues which plague this game.

Warning! This post may contain traces of irony, sarcasm and peanuts.

There is no loyalty without betrayal. -Ann Smiley